ACL Graft Selection: Patellar vs Hamstring

What Are Anterior Cruciate Ligaments?

The anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) is one of the major stabilizing ligaments in the knee, located inside the joint and connecting the femur to the tibia. Its primary function is to prevent forward movement of the lower leg relative to the upper leg.

Injuries to the ACL are common, often occurring during sports activities that involve sudden stops or changes in direction.

Graft Selection for ACL Reconstruction

When an ACL is torn and surgery is necessary, doctors must choose a graft from which to reconstruct the ligament. Common choices include patellar tendon, hamstring tendon, and allograft (donor tissue).

Patellar tendon and hamstring tendon are autograft options, meaning they come from the patient’s own body, typically taken during the same surgical procedure.

live demo · related simulation● LIVE

Comparing Patellar Tendon and Hamstring Tendon

The patellar tendon is strong and provides excellent mechanical properties for grafting. However, it can cause pain in the front of the knee (patellar tendinopathy) due to its location and size.

Hamstring tendons are less invasive to harvest and have a lower risk of postoperative pain compared to the patellar tendon. They also provide good strength but may be more prone to graft failure if not properly prepared.

Factors Influencing Graft Choice

Several factors influence which type of graft is chosen, including patient age, activity level, and previous knee injuries.

For instance, younger, more active patients may prefer the stronger patellar tendon for its durability, while older or less active patients might opt for the hamstring tendon to reduce pain risk.

Frequently asked questions

What are the main benefits of using a patellar tendon graft?

Patellar tendon grafts provide excellent mechanical properties and strength, making them suitable for high-demand activities. They also heal faster compared to other types of grafts.

Why might a surgeon choose a hamstring tendon over a patellar tendon?

Hamstring tendons are less likely to cause pain in the front of the knee and have a lower risk of complications such as patellar tendinopathy. They also require a smaller incision, making them a more minimally invasive option.

Can both grafts be used interchangeably?

While both are viable options, the choice depends on various factors including patient needs and surgeon preference. Patellar tendon is often chosen for its strength, while hamstring tendon is preferred for lower pain risk.

What happens if a graft fails after ACL reconstruction?

If a graft fails, it may require additional surgery to replace the graft or repair any complications that arose from the initial procedure. The success rate of these revisions can vary based on several factors including the type of graft used and patient compliance.

Try it live

Everything above runs in your browser — open ACL Graft Selection (Patellar vs Hamstring) Simulator and change the parameters while it is running. Nothing is installed, nothing is uploaded, the whole model lives in one tab.

▶ Open ACL Graft Selection (Patellar vs Hamstring) Simulator simulation