The Science Behind Gerrymandering: Packing, Cracking, and…

What Gerrymandering Is

Gerrymandering is the practice of drawing district boundaries to favor one party or group over another. This can be achieved by 'packing' opposing voters into a few districts, ensuring their votes are wasted, or by 'cracking' them across many districts so that they have less influence in any single area.

The term originates from 1812 when Massachusetts Governor Elbridge Gerry signed a bill redrawing district boundaries to favor his party. A map of one district resembled a salamander, leading to the coining of 'gerrymandering'.

Packing and Cracking in Action

When districts are packed, opposing voters are concentrated into a few areas, diluting their influence elsewhere. This can be seen as creating safe seats for one party where the other has no chance of winning.

Cracking, on the other hand, spreads out these voters across many districts, ensuring that even if they win some seats, they do not have enough votes to control a majority.

live demo · related simulation● LIVE

The Efficiency Gap

The efficiency gap quantifies how much one party's votes are wasted compared to the other. It measures the difference between the wasted votes of each party and is used as an indicator of whether a districting plan is fair or biased.

A high efficiency gap suggests that gerrymandering has occurred, as it indicates that one party’s votes have been significantly more effective than the other's.

Why It Matters

Gerrymandering can lead to a distortion of democratic representation. If districts are drawn in a way that favors one party, it can result in a legislature that does not accurately reflect the will of the electorate.

This can have significant implications for policy-making and governance, potentially leading to laws and policies that do not serve all constituents equally.

Frequently asked questions

How is the efficiency gap calculated?

The efficiency gap is calculated by subtracting the wasted votes of one party from those of the other, then dividing by the total number of votes cast. Wasted votes are those that do not contribute to electing a candidate.

Is gerrymandering legal?

Gerrymandering itself is not illegal in the United States, but extreme cases can be challenged under the Constitution and other laws. The Supreme Court has ruled on several instances of alleged gerrymandering.

Can technology help prevent gerrymandering?

Yes, various algorithms and tools are being developed to create more fair district maps. These aim to minimize the efficiency gap and ensure that districts are drawn in a way that reflects the true preferences of voters.

What is the role of redistricting commissions?

Redistricting commissions, often composed of non-partisan members, can be established to draw district boundaries without political influence. This approach aims to reduce gerrymandering and ensure fair representation.

Try it live

Everything above runs in your browser — open Gerrymandering Simulator — Packing & Cracking Districts and change the parameters while it is running. Nothing is installed, nothing is uploaded, the whole model lives in one tab.

▶ Open Gerrymandering Simulator — Packing & Cracking Districts simulation

The Science Behind Gerrymandering: Packing, Cracking, and Efficiency Gap