Screw Jack: Mechanical Advantage, Thread Friction and Self-Locking

Turn the handle of a Blender-built screw jack with real 12, 6 and 3 mm threads: the ideal advantage 2 pi l / L, the friction torque, the efficiency and when the load locks itself.

Switch to 2D

Presets

Playback

Parameters

Camera

Layers

Quality

Model check

The science

A screw is a wrapped ramp. Unwrap one turn of the thread and you get an inclined plane of length sqrt((pi d)^2 + L^2) and height L, where L is the lead (advance per turn) and d the mean thread diameter. The handle trades distance for force: with no friction, effort times the path of your hand 2 pi l equals the load times the lead, so the ideal mechanical advantage is 2 pi l / L. A fine thread (small L) and a long handle give a huge advantage, at the price of many turns.

Friction. With a thread friction coefficient mu on the ramp, the torque to raise the load is T = (W d/2)(tan(lam) + mu)/(1 - mu tan(lam)) plus the friction of the thrust collar, W mu_c d_c / 2. The efficiency e = W L/(2 pi T) is the useful work over the work you do. When mu is at least tan(lam) the lowering torque is positive: friction beats the load's pull and the screw is self-locking, which is why jacks and vises stay where you leave them (and why efficient screws such as ball screws are not). A self-locking screw cannot be more than 50 % efficient.

What is simplified. Square threads (an Acme or metric thread has a flank angle that raises the effective friction), constant friction coefficients, no starting (static) friction peak, no elastic deformation of the screw, no inertia of the handle, perfect axial load. The jack is drawn at its real size; the load block is only a visual marker, the load is the mass slider.

Numerical checks (run on load): the closed-form torque against a numerical solution of the force balance on the unwrapped thread; the energy over one turn split into load energy, thread friction and collar friction; the maximum efficiency found by scanning the lead angle against (1 - sin phi)/(1 + sin phi); and the lead of the three Blender-built threads measured from their mesh vertices, together with the rendered rise of the platform per turn.

Loading model...
Loading Blender model...
Handle effort against thread lead, with and without friction
Efficiency against lead angle for different friction coefficients
Work by hand, load energy and heat against lift
Made with 🟠 Blender · Three.js