Football Free Kick - Magnus Curl and Drag Crisis (3D)

A free kick over a four-man wall on a Blender-built pitch: spin curls the ball, and the drag coefficient collapses as it passes the critical speed.

Switch to 2D

Presets

Playback

Kick

Distance, speed and direction of the free kick.

Spin and air

Spin rates of the ball and a crosswind.

Ball

Seams and panels shift the speed at which drag collapses.

Camera

Quality

Layers

Model checks

The science

Forces on the ball

Three forces act: gravity m g, drag Fd = ½ ρ Cd A v2 opposing the velocity relative to the air, and the Magnus force FM = ½ ρ A CL v2 along ω × v. A spinning ball drags a thin layer of air around with it; the air on one side is sped up and on the other slowed, the pressure is lower on the fast side, and the ball is pushed sideways. I use the lift fit CL = 1 / (2 + v / (R ω)), so faster spin bends the path more and the lift saturates near 0.5.

The drag crisis

Drag on a sphere is not constant. Below a critical Reynolds number (Re = v D / ν, about 2 to 3 × 105, i.e. 15 to 20 m/s for a football) the boundary layer separates early and Cd ≈ 0.47; above it the layer turns turbulent, clings to the ball longer, the wake shrinks and Cd drops to about 0.2. Seams and panels trip the layer earlier, so a rougher ball enters the crisis at a lower speed. Here Cd(v) is a smooth step between 0.47 and 0.22 centred on the critical speed (adjust with the roughness slider). A medium-speed, spin-free kick (about 18 to 20 m/s, a chip or lob) therefore decelerates more and more as it falls through the crisis and drops steeply; a hard drive leaves the foot far above the critical speed and is barely affected. The dashed orange path shows the same kick with constant Cd.

Integration and checks

The state is advanced by classical fourth-order Runge-Kutta with a 2 ms step. Three closed forms check it independently: the vacuum range v2 sin 2α / g, one-dimensional quadratic drag x = ln(1 + k v0 t) / k, and a pure Magnus force, which must give a circle of radius v2 / aM at constant speed because it does no work.

Honest simplifications: Cd follows a smooth empirical step, not measured data; the lift fit is the common textbook one; spin decays with a fixed 20 s time constant; no ball deformation, no unsteady knuckle-ball side forces (the dip and float come only from the drag crisis), no bounce, no goalkeeper, and the wall is four static players, 1.80 m tall, 9.15 m from the ball. Air is at 1.2 kg/m3 and 15 degrees C. Not a model of any particular player or manufacturer's ball.

What to try
  • Choose Curler round the wall: the ball leaves outside the post line and Magnus bends it into the goal. Set side spin to zero and watch it miss.
  • Pick Drag-crisis chip and compare the yellow and dashed orange paths: the crisis makes the real ball slow down more than the constant-Cd ball, and the graph of speed against time shows where.
  • Drag roughness from 0 to 1 (or compare the smooth and rough chip presets) and see the critical speed in the first graph move from 20 down to 11 m/s.
  • Add a crosswind and try to cancel it with side spin; the third graph shows the offset for every spin.
Loading Blender model...
Drag coefficient against speed (the drag crisis)
Speed against time: crisis model, constant Cd, no air
Sideways offset at the goal line against side spin
Made with 🟠 Blender · Three.js