Lunar Laser Ranging: Photon Budget, Poisson Returns and Tidal Recession of the Moon

A dome observatory tracks a laser pulse to a corner-cube array on the Moon (not to scale): Kepler distance, the r^-4 photon budget, Poisson returns and the slow tidal recession. Drag to orbit.

Switch to 2D
Controls

Presets

Parameters

Quality

Camera

Model checks

The science

What is measured. Apollo 11, 14 and 15 and two Soviet Lunokhod rovers left arrays of corner-cube retroreflectors on the Moon. An observatory fires a short 532 nm laser pulse through its telescope, a cube array sends a few photons straight back, and the round-trip time gives the distance, d = c τ / 2. The distance is not constant: the orbit is an ellipse, so the Moon swings between about 356 and 407 thousand km (the mean orbit used here, with e = 0.0549, gives 363 to 406 thousand km; the real extremes include solar perturbations).

Orbit. Mean anomaly M = M0 + 2πt/T with T = 2π√(a³/G(ME+m)) (27.3 days); Kepler's equation M = E - e sin E is solved by Newton iteration and r = a(1 - e cos E). The page does not include the solar perturbations, so it is a two-body orbit.

Photon budget. The uplink beam is a Gaussian with FWHM θup = √((1.22 λ/D)² + seeing²), so on the Moon its standard deviation is σ = θup r / 2.355 (a few km). The fraction landing on an array of equivalent radius ra is 1 - exp(-ra²/2σ²). Each cube (38 mm) diffracts the return into θret = √((1.22 λ/d)² + θva²), about 18 microradians including velocity aberration, so the return footprint on Earth is several km wide while the telescope is metres; the fraction collected is again a Gaussian encircled energy. Both fractions fall as r-2, hence the famous r-4 law: the expected photoelectrons per shot are n = (E/hν) pup pdn η with η the product of transmit and receive optics, detector quantum efficiency, array efficiency and two-way atmospheric transmission exp(-2τ0/sin(elevation)). With n well below 1 most shots return nothing, which is why a real station fires 20 pulses a second for minutes.

Detection. The number of photoelectrons in a shot is Poisson distributed, so the chance of at least one return is 1 - e-n; background counts in the range gate add a noise rate (sky and sunlit lunar surface, counts per second times gate width). The range precision of N returns is the timing jitter (200 ps = 30 mm) divided by √N.

Why the Moon recedes. The Moon raises tidal bulges on Earth; because Earth turns faster than the Moon orbits, the bulge leads and pulls the Moon forward. The torque is N = (3/2)(k2/Q) G m² RE5/a6. The orbital angular momentum L = m√(G ME a) grows by exactly what Earth's spin loses, so da/dt = 2aN/L = K a-11/2. The effective k2/Q = 0.0258 (ocean tides included) reproduces the measured recession of about 3.8 cm per year; Earth's day then lengthens by about 2 ms per century from the lunar tide.

What the checks compare. (1) The Kepler solver against perigee and apogee a(1 -/+ e), vis-viva, and the speed obtained from finite differences of the solved positions. (2) The Gaussian encircled-energy formula against a Monte Carlo of 200,000 photon landing points. (3) A Monte Carlo of 100,000 Poisson laser shots against 1 - e-n and the mean count. (4) The r-4 scaling between perigee and apogee, and for a doubled range. (5) A 500-million-year RK4 integration of the recession against the closed form a13/2 = a013/2 + (13/2)Kt, an angular-momentum ledger between Earth spin and orbit, and a hand-derived rate per unit k2/Q.

Simplifications, honestly. The array efficiency, atmospheric extinction, detector and optics numbers are plausible illustrative values, not those of any real station, so the absolute photoelectron rates are not predictions of a real observatory. The Moon's libration, the finite pulse length, speckle, scintillation, pointing errors and the three-body perturbations are ignored. The epoch slider extrapolates the present tidal model with a constant k2/Q, which is wrong over geological time (the real tidal response depended on the ocean basins); it only shows the form of the recession law. The scene is not to scale and the orbit's eccentricity is exaggerated in the pictures.

Loading model...
Loading Blender model...
-
-
Made with 🟠 Blender · Three.js