RTG vs Solar Power

2D companion of the 3D power-versus-distance lab: where does the solar array stop being worth carrying?

Switch to 3D

Presets

Playback

Apparatus

Model checks

The science

What is modelled

Sunlight spreads over a sphere, so the flux and the solar-array power fall as 1/d². An RTG makes its heat from the decay of Pu-238 (half-life 87.7 years) and turns a few percent of it into electricity with thermocouples, so its output does not depend on distance at all.

Equations

  • Flux S(d) = S0 / d² with S0 = L / (4 π (1 AU)²) = 1361 W/m²; array power Ps = S A η (1 − r)t.
  • RTG heat Q(t) = Q0 2−t/87.7 yr, electric power Pr = ηc Q(t) (1 − 0.008)t.
  • Crossover d* = √(S0 A η (1 − r)t / Pr).

Checks run in the page

  • Inverse square against the solar luminosity and the doubling rule.
  • Numerical decay against the half-life formula.
  • Closed-form crossover against bisection of the two power curves.

Honest simplifications

The array always faces the Sun, its efficiency does not change with temperature or low light, the thermocouple ageing is a flat 0.8 % per year, and the spacecraft needs are not modelled. It shows the trend and the crossover, not a design.

What to try
  • Press Earth orbit, launch and compare the two bars; then drag the distance towards Jupiter.
  • Press Saturn, year 12 and find how many square metres of array are needed to match the RTG.
  • Move the years to 87.7 and see the plutonium heat halve exactly.
Power against distance (log-log)
Power against years at this distance
Crossover distance against years
Remaining fraction against years