Roche limit - 2D orbital-plane N-body

A rubble-pile moon spirals toward its planet: tidal stretching, the Hill sphere and the rigid and fluid Roche limits.

Switch to 3D

Presets

Playback

Parameters

Model checks

The science

Tides versus self-gravity

A moon of mass m and radius Rm at distance d from a planet of mass M feels a tidal acceleration across its radius of about 3GM Rm/d3 (including the centrifugal part for a locked moon), while its own gravity at the surface is Gm/Rm2. Their ratio Π = 3 M Rm3 /(m d3) crosses 1 at the Hill-sphere distance dH = Rp (3 ρp/ρm)1/3 = 1.442 Rp (ρp/ρm)1/3, independent of moon size.

Rigid and fluid Roche limits

Edouard Roche (1848) showed that a fluid, self-gravitating moon deforms into an ellipsoid and breaks up inside dfluid = 2.456 Rp (ρp/ρm)1/3. A rigid body held together by material strength survives to drigid = 1.26 Rp (ρp/ρm)1/3. A rubble pile held only by gravity lies between them.

What the sim does

The moon is 60-300 equal-mass particles in the orbital plane with softened mutual gravity (planar slice of 3D masses), orbiting a fixed planet. Orbital decay is an optional drag. The simulation runs a leapfrog integrator with energy diagnostics. The numerical check integrates a test particle in the rotating-frame restricted three-body problem and finds the distance at which a particle on the moon's surface first escapes, comparing it with the exact L1 point and the Hill formula.

Honest simplifications: two dimensions, no moon spin or internal pressure, no strength (rubble pile), a fixed planet (the planet's recoil is negligible for these mass ratios), softened forces, and a gravity-only particle cloud that is only a rough stand-in for a fluid. Debris does not coalesce into proper rings. The measured breakup distance of the particle cloud is therefore an illustration within the rigid-to-fluid bracket, not a precision value.

What to try
  • Start at 5 planetary radii with decay on and watch the moon stretch along the planet axis.
  • Lower the moon density: the Roche limit moves outward, the moon dies earlier.
  • Compare a dense iron moon (8) with an icy one (1).
Bound fraction and tidal ratio vs time
Critical distance vs density ratio
Orbit: distance to planet vs time