Earth-Moon Tidal Recession (2D)

Polar view of the leading tidal bulge, the torques and the Moon drifting outwards through geological time.

Switch to 3D

Presets

Playback

Time

Geological time runs in millions of years per second.

Tides

How leaky the tides are and how heavy the Moon is.

Starting point (t = 0)

Present Moon distance and day length, and how big the bulge is drawn.

Layers

Model checks

The science

The Moon raises a tide, and the tide pulls back

The Moon pulls the near side of the Earth harder than the far side, which stretches the oceans and the solid Earth into two bulges along the Earth–Moon line. Because the Earth spins faster (once per day) than the Moon orbits (once per 27.3 days), friction in the oceans and mantle drags the bulge ahead of the line to the Moon by a small lag angle δ, where sin 2δ = 1/Q. The Moon then pulls the forward bulge backwards (slowing the spin) while the bulge pulls the Moon forwards (raising its orbit). For an equilibrium tide with Love number k2 the torque and the rate of recession are

N = (3/2) k2 (G m2 R5 / a6) sin 2δ,    da/dt = 3 (k2/Q) (m/M) (R/a)5 n a

The Earth–Moon system keeps its total angular momentum, so what the spin loses the orbit gains:

L = C ω + μ √(G (M+m) a) = constant,    dLorb/dt = N = − C dω/dt

The energy is not conserved: the power N(ω − n) is dissipated as heat in the oceans and the interior (about 3–4 TW today). Because da/dt ∝ a−11/2, the Moon was receding much faster in the past; going back far enough with a constant k2/Q the Moon reaches the Roche limit (about 2.9 Earth radii) in well under 2 billion years, which is much too recent — the famous “time problem”. In reality ocean tides depend strongly on the shape of the continents, so Q was not constant.

What the page computes

  • da/dt and dω/dt from the formulas above, integrated forward and backward with RK4 in 1-million-year steps; day length = 2π/ω, days per year = 1 year / day length.
  • With k2/Q = 0.027 the present recession is about 3.8 cm/yr (measured by laser ranging to the Apollo mirrors: 3.83 ± 0.07 cm/yr) and the day lengthens about 2 ms per century by lunar tides.
  • Fossil corals and bivalves keep daily growth bands: about 400–410 days per year in the Devonian (about 400 million years ago). The green marks are approximate published values, not a fit.

Honest simplifications

  • Constant k2/Q and a single equilibrium tide on the Earth; no solar tides, no tide raised on the Moon, no change of the Moon’s spin, no obliquity or eccentricity, no core–mantle coupling and no climate-driven changes of the day (post-glacial rebound and sea level partly offset the tidal slowdown today: the observed lengthening is about 1.7 ms/century).
  • The drawn bulge is exaggerated in height and in lag angle (slider); the real bulge is about 0.5 m high and the real lag is about 3 degrees. The scene compresses the Earth–Moon distance (the true value is 60 Earth radii) and spins faster than real life.
  • Ocean tides today are dissipated mainly in shallow seas, so the value of k2/Q here is an effective one chosen to reproduce the measured recession.
What to try
  • Press Play and watch the Moon drift outwards while the day gets longer; jump to Devonian seas and read about 400 days in the year and a 22-hour day.
  • Switch on the forces: the green arrow pulls the Moon forward, the red arrow brakes the Earth's spin — equal and opposite torques about the same line.
  • Drag k2/Q down (high Q): the recession and the day-length change slow in proportion; up (low Q) and the Moon rushes outwards.
  • Run Back to the Roche limit: the model puts the Moon on the Earth's surface far too recently — the sign that Q was not constant.
  • Try a heavy Moon: the tidal torque grows with m2, so everything speeds up.
Moon distance against time (Roche limit in red)
Length of the day against time
Days in a year against time (fossil bands in green)
Recession rate against Moon distance