🌍 Life Cycle Assessment: Product Footprint Comparison Lab

2D interactive simulation · educational model
The science

Life cycle assessment (LCA) adds up the environmental burden of a product over every stage of its life for one functional unit — the same amount of service (e.g. 25,000 hours of light, 150,000 km driven, 100 shopping trips), so that different products are compared fairly. This lab follows the ISO 14040/44 idea of goal, inventory and impact with a single indicator: kg CO2-equivalent (a global-warming potential).

The model. With N = ⌈F / L⌉ units needed to deliver the service F from a product whose life is L: total = N (mmat + mmfg + mtr d/1000 + meol(1 − 0.8 r)) + F (eel I/1000 + efuel), where d is shipping distance (km), r the end-of-life recycling rate (recycling credits cut the end-of-life burden by up to 80% — an assumption), I the grid carbon intensity in g CO2/kWh, eel the electricity per unit of service (kWh) and efuel direct fuel emissions per unit. A product with a high "up-front" burden and low running burden wins only beyond the break-even amount of service F* = (aB − aA) / (bA − bB), where a is the one-off burden and b the burden per unit of service. The grid intensity slider shows how the winner can flip with the electricity mix (plot on the right).

Honest simplifications. All inventory numbers are illustrative round values of a realistic order of magnitude, NOT a certified assessment of any real product, brand or model. One indicator only (no water, toxicity, land use, resource depletion); no uncertainty ranges; no allocation, rebound effects or battery ageing; recycling credit is a flat 0.8 factor; a real LCA needs a full inventory database. Use it to understand how the comparison is structured, not to pick a product.