Negotiate a workplace dispute over four issues: see why splitting everything 50/50 leaves value on the table and how trading issues reaches the Pareto frontier.
Setup. Two parties split four issues (budget, deadline, headcount, remote days). Party A values issue i at weight wA,i, party B at wB,i, each set summing to 1. If A takes share xi of issue i, then UA = ΣwA,ixi and UB = ΣwB,i(1 − xi).
Pareto frontier. The best possible deals give each issue to the party that values it relatively more: sort issues by wA/wB and hand them to A from the top (fractional knapsack). A 50/50 split of every issue gives about (0.5, 0.5), which usually lies strictly inside the frontier: trading ("log-rolling") makes both sides better off at once, the integrative gain.
Nash bargaining. With disagreement payoffs (BATNAs) dA, dB, the Nash solution maximises (UA − dA)(UB − dB) on the frontier; a strong BATNA moves it toward its owner. The style labels (competing, accommodating, compromising, collaborating, avoiding) follow the Thomas-Kilmann idea of assertiveness vs cooperativeness; here they are only a heuristic reading of the position.
Honest limits: linear utilities, fixed known weights, one round, no emotion, trust or hidden information, which real negotiations have. Teaching model only.