Management Conflict Resolution Simulation

Negotiate a workplace dispute over four issues: see why splitting everything 50/50 leaves value on the table and how trading issues reaches the Pareto frontier.

Controls

Readouts

Independent check

...
The science

Setup. Two parties split four issues (budget, deadline, headcount, remote days). Party A values issue i at weight wA,i, party B at wB,i, each set summing to 1. If A takes share xi of issue i, then UA = ΣwA,ixi and UB = ΣwB,i(1 − xi).

Pareto frontier. The best possible deals give each issue to the party that values it relatively more: sort issues by wA/wB and hand them to A from the top (fractional knapsack). A 50/50 split of every issue gives about (0.5, 0.5), which usually lies strictly inside the frontier: trading ("log-rolling") makes both sides better off at once, the integrative gain.

Nash bargaining. With disagreement payoffs (BATNAs) dA, dB, the Nash solution maximises (UA − dA)(UB − dB) on the frontier; a strong BATNA moves it toward its owner. The style labels (competing, accommodating, compromising, collaborating, avoiding) follow the Thomas-Kilmann idea of assertiveness vs cooperativeness; here they are only a heuristic reading of the position.

Honest limits: linear utilities, fixed known weights, one round, no emotion, trust or hidden information, which real negotiations have. Teaching model only.