⚛️ Matter Replicator Energy Bill: E = mc2 vs Atom-by-Atom Assembly

Check

Presets

Controls

Readouts

The science

Thought experiment, not a device. Nothing like a replicator exists; the point is to see what physics would charge for one.

Route A: create the mass from energy. E = m c² (c² = 8.988 x 1016 J/kg), so 1 g costs about 9 x 1013 J (25 GWh). But protons and neutrons are baryons: baryon number is conserved, so pair production makes a particle together with its antiparticle (a net 2 m c² for matter plus the same mass of antimatter, which would annihilate with the product if they touched). Making an electron-positron pair needs 2 x 0.511 MeV; a proton-antiproton pair 1.88 GeV. The plot uses 2 m c².

Route B: assemble from feedstock. Rearranging existing atoms needs no new mass, only chemistry and positioning. Energy = N (atoms) x Eplace (illustrative; scanning-probe atom manipulation is of order a few eV per move, here a free parameter) + N x bits x kB T ln 2 (Landauer cost of erasing the blueprint bits at 300 K) + n ΔHf (standard formation enthalpy from the elements; negative means heat is released). Time = N / (assemblers x rate). The enormous gap between A and B (about 109 or more) is the lesson: copying matter is cheap in energy but slow, creating it is fast in principle but absurdly expensive.

Check: the sum of the constituent masses of one formula unit exceeds the measured molar mass by roughly 0.7-0.9 %, the mass defect of nuclear binding (about 8 MeV per nucleon), consistent with E = mc².

Simplifications: no efficiency or waste-heat model for route A, no error correction, no radiation shielding, one structure type, thermodynamic placement cost not derived. Formation enthalpies are standard textbook values; the placement energy, assembler count and rate are made-up knobs. Educational only.