Frigatebird Thermal Soaring: Glider Polar, Bank Angle and Climb in a Gaussian Thermal

A frigatebird circles in a thermal under a cumulus cloud: the glide polar, the banked-circle sink and the updraft profile decide how fast it climbs, and a follower bird glides in to share the lift.

Switch to 2D

Presets

Playback

Parameters

Camera

Layers

Quality

Model check

The science

What is modelled

A great frigatebird (about 1.5 kg, 2.3 m span) gains height for free by circling in a thermal, a column of warm rising air under a cumulus cloud. Three pieces of physics decide how fast it climbs: the glide polar (how much height the wing loses per second at a given speed), the geometry of a banked circle (steeper bank means a smaller circle but more sink), and the shape of the updraft (strongest in the core, fading outwards). The page also shows a second bird gliding in from 700 m away to share the thermal, and a simple thermalling rule that moves the circle toward the strongest lift.

Equations

  • Lift coefficient in a turn at bank φ: CL = 2 m g / (ρ V² S cosφ); drag polar CD = CD0 + k CL² with k = 1/(π e AR), AR = b²/S (here b = 2.3 m, S = 0.55 m², e = 0.8, CD0 = 0.032).
  • Sink rate: ws = D V / (m g) = ρ V³ S CD / (2 m g). Air density falls with height, ρ = 1.225 e-h/8500 m.
  • Circle at constant airspeed: r = V² / (g tanφ), turn rate g tanφ / V, load factor 1/cosφ, stall speed rises as 1/√cosφ (CLmax = 1.6).
  • Thermal: w(r) = w0 exp(-(r/R)²). A centred circle climbs at w(r) - ws(V, φ); the page maximises this over V and φ on a grid, refined three times.
  • Best glide and minimum sink follow from the polar: L/Dmax = 1/(2√(CD0 k)) at CL = √(CD0/k), minimum sink at CL = √(3 CD0/k).
  • Thermalling rule: the bird records the vertical air speed against heading over the last full turn; the lift-weighted mean heading points tangentially past the core, and slowing the turn when the bird points at the core (turn rate × (1 − 0.7 cos(ψ − ψbest))) walks the circle toward the lift.

Checks run in the page

  • Numerical search of the polar against the closed forms for L/D and minimum sink.
  • Integration of a banked turn for one period (closes on itself; sink grows with bank).
  • Optimum circle: the uniform-updraft limit and the narrow versus broad thermal trend.
  • Closed-loop thermalling from 100 m off the core to cloud base, and the lift-weighted direction estimator.
  • Integrated glide over 5 km against distance divided by L/D, and the Blender model span and planform area against the polar's S and AR.

Honest simplifications

  • The aerodynamic constants (CD0, e, wing area, CLmax) are representative of a large soaring seabird, not measurements of one individual; real birds also change wing shape, which this fixed polar cannot capture.
  • The thermal is a static Gaussian column without a sinking collar, turbulence, wind drift, shear or a life cycle; real thermals are far less tidy, and the climb rates here are best read as ideal values.
  • The thermalling rule is a plausible simple feedback, not a model of how birds actually sense lift. The follower bird simply knows where the thermal is.
  • The bird is drawn seven times life size so it can be seen against a 110 m thermal; all physics uses the true size.

What to try

  • Switch off the optimum and set the bank to 55 degrees: the circle is tight but the sink penalty eats the climb (first graph).
  • Make the thermal narrow (R = 50 m) and weak (2 m/s) and see how little climb is left; widen it and the bird relaxes to a shallow bank.
  • Turn off the thermalling rule with a large start offset and watch the climb stay poor.
Loading model...
Loading Blender model...
Net climb against bank angle (centred circle)
Updraft and net climb across the thermal
Altitude of the two birds against time
Made with 🟠 Blender · Three.js