Dispersive Water Wave Packet: Phase vs Group Velocity in a Wave Tank

A glass wave tank with a travelling packet of water waves, tracer particles that trace the orbits, a red pin on one crest and a green pin on the packet. Drag to orbit.

Switch to 2D
Controls

Presets

Parameters

Quality

Camera

Model checks

The science

Dispersion. Small-amplitude gravity waves on water of constant depth h obey the dispersion relation ω² = g k tanh(kh), with k = 2π/λ. In deep water (kh > π) this is ω = √(gk): long waves are faster. In shallow water (kh < π/10) it becomes ω = k√(gh): all wavelengths travel at the same speed √(gh) and there is no dispersion. Surface tension (relevant below a few centimetres) is not included.

Phase speed and group speed. A single crest moves with the phase speed c = ω/k, but the energy of a wave packet moves with the group speed cg = dω/dk = (c/2)[1 + 2kh/sinh(2kh)]. In deep water cg = c/2, so individual crests run forward through the packet, appear at its back and vanish at its front; in shallow water cg = c. The red pin rides one crest, the green pin sits at the energy centre of the packet. The packet is a Gaussian superposition of waves with wavenumbers around k0 (the more waves in the packet, the narrower the spectrum and the less it spreads).

Particle orbits. Water particles move on closed paths: ξ = −a cosh(k(z+h))/sinh(kh) sin θ, ζ = a sinh(k(z+h))/sinh(kh) cos θ. They are circles that shrink as exp(kz) with depth in deep water and flatten into back-and-forth ellipses near a floor in shallow water; the waves transport energy, not water.

Energy. The energy per unit area is E = ½ρg a², half potential and half kinetic (equipartition), and the energy flux is E cg per metre of crest.

What the five checks compare. (1) A Newton solver for k(ω) against the forward relation ω(k) at 16 depth and wavelength combinations. (2) A Richardson-extrapolated numerical derivative dω/dk against the closed-form group speed. (3) Tracking one crest frame by frame against ω/k. (4) The kinetic energy integrated numerically over the depth and one wavelength against the potential energy ¼ρg a² (equipartition, which validates the velocity field used for the orbits). (5) The motion of the energy centroid of the full multi-mode packet against the spectrum-weighted group speed, plus the Parseval energy sum.

Simplifications and honest limits. Linear theory: valid for small steepness (a k below about 0.3; real waves steepen and break near a k = 0.44 in deep water), constant depth, no wind, no currents, no viscosity, no surface tension and no reflection (the tank is periodic: the packet re-enters on the left). The picture is a stylised tank: wave heights and orbits are drawn eight times too large so they can be seen; the depth and the horizontal wavelength are to scale. Constants: g = 9.80665 m/s² (standard gravity) and ρ = 1000 kg/m³ are used; the dispersion relation is the standard Airy result found in any coastal-engineering text.

Loading model...
Loading Blender model...
-
-
Made with 🟠 Blender · Three.js