Renewable harvest and retrofit economics lab

A harvested stock and a learning-curve retrofit: sustainable yield, profit, NPV and payback with analytic checks.

Presets

Playback

Resource and retrofit

Camera

Layers

Quality

Model check

The science

What is modelled

Two small, standard models share one site. A renewable stock (a managed fishery, forest or aquifer: the tank) regrows logistically and is harvested with effort E; the page shows when a harvest is sustainable, when it earns the most money and when it collapses the stock. An efficiency retrofit (modules on the rack) lowers the cost of each unit of effort; module prices fall along a learning curve and the page values the investment with net present value, payback and internal rate of return. The placeholder page that held this id contained no model; this is an educational sketch of established textbook formulas, not business advice and not a model of any real organisation. Money is in abstract units.

Equations

  • Stock S: dS/dt = r S (1 - S/K) - q E S (Schaefer 1954). With qE < r the stable equilibrium is S* = K (1 - qE/r), the yield Y = qE S* peaks at the maximum sustainable yield MSY = rK/4 at EMSY = r/(2q). Above E = r/q the stock decays to zero. K = 1000 and q = 0.004 are fixed.
  • Profit per year π = p q E S - ceff E. At equilibrium it is maximal at EMEY = (r/2q)(1 - c/(pqK)), below EMSY; with free entry effort grows until profit is zero at EOA = (r/q)(1 - c/(pqK)) (Gordon 1954).
  • Learning curve (Wright): the k-th module costs c0 k-b with b = -log2(LR), so each doubling of the number built multiplies cost by LR. Total price of n modules is the sum over k = 1..n.
  • Each module cuts the cost per unit effort by δ (capped at 80 % in total), so yearly savings are A = min(0.8, nδ) c E.
  • NPV = -I + A (1 - (1+d)-T)/d, discounted payback t = -ln(1 - I d / A)/ln(1+d) rounded up to a whole year, and the IRR is the d at which NPV = 0.

Checks run in the page

  • RK4 integration of the stock equation against the analytic equilibrium and against the exact logistic solution after 12 years.
  • A brute-force scan of 6,000 effort values against the closed forms for MSY, EMSY, EMEY and EOA.
  • NPV by the annuity formula against the year-by-year discounted sum; payback by formula against a scan; the IRR substituted back to give NPV = 0.
  • Learning curve: the doubling ratio equals LR for several k, and a log-log regression over 64 modules recovers the exponent -b.

Honest simplifications

  • Real stocks have age structure, spatial structure, noisy recruitment and delays; the Schaefer model has none of these and can understate collapse risk. Price and cost are constants here, with no market feedback.
  • The learning rate is a fitted empirical regularity, not a law, and varies widely by technology. Savings are assumed constant for the whole horizon (no degradation, no tax, no inflation, no maintenance), and the retrofit does not change the harvest.
  • Discounting treats a unit of money in the future as worth less today; the choice of d encodes how much weight is put on the future and is a value judgement, not a measured number. At d = 0 the NPV is a simple sum.
  • The crates in the 3D view count cumulative harvest (one per 120 units); the cash bar shows the NPV (1 unit of height per 100 money units, red when negative). The flowing particles are illustrative.

What to try

  • Move E from 0 to 50 and watch yield rise to MSY; push it to 80 and profit falls to about zero while the stock sits near 200 of 1000 (open access).
  • Set E = 110: effort exceeds r/q = 100 and the stock decays towards zero.
  • Raise the learning rate to 98 % and the discount rate to 12 %: the retrofit stops paying back inside the horizon.
Loading model...
Loading Blender model...
Stock over time
Revenue, cost and profit against effort
Cumulative discounted cash flow of the retrofit
Learning curve: cost of the k-th module
Made with 🟠 Blender · Three.js