Presets
Playback
Resource and retrofit
Camera
Layers
Quality
Model check
The science
What is modelled
Two small, standard models share one site. A renewable stock (a managed fishery, forest or aquifer: the tank) regrows logistically and is harvested with effort E; the page shows when a harvest is sustainable, when it earns the most money and when it collapses the stock. An efficiency retrofit (modules on the rack) lowers the cost of each unit of effort; module prices fall along a learning curve and the page values the investment with net present value, payback and internal rate of return. The placeholder page that held this id contained no model; this is an educational sketch of established textbook formulas, not business advice and not a model of any real organisation. Money is in abstract units.
Equations
- Stock S:
dS/dt = r S (1 - S/K) - q E S(Schaefer 1954). WithqE < rthe stable equilibrium isS* = K (1 - qE/r), the yieldY = qE S*peaks at the maximum sustainable yieldMSY = rK/4atEMSY = r/(2q). AboveE = r/qthe stock decays to zero. K = 1000 and q = 0.004 are fixed. - Profit per year
π = p q E S - ceff E. At equilibrium it is maximal atEMEY = (r/2q)(1 - c/(pqK)), below EMSY; with free entry effort grows until profit is zero atEOA = (r/q)(1 - c/(pqK))(Gordon 1954). - Learning curve (Wright): the k-th module costs
c0 k-bwithb = -log2(LR), so each doubling of the number built multiplies cost by LR. Total price of n modules is the sum over k = 1..n. - Each module cuts the cost per unit effort by δ (capped at 80 % in total), so yearly savings are
A = min(0.8, nδ) c E. NPV = -I + A (1 - (1+d)-T)/d, discounted paybackt = -ln(1 - I d / A)/ln(1+d)rounded up to a whole year, and the IRR is the d at which NPV = 0.
Checks run in the page
- RK4 integration of the stock equation against the analytic equilibrium and against the exact logistic solution after 12 years.
- A brute-force scan of 6,000 effort values against the closed forms for MSY, EMSY, EMEY and EOA.
- NPV by the annuity formula against the year-by-year discounted sum; payback by formula against a scan; the IRR substituted back to give NPV = 0.
- Learning curve: the doubling ratio equals LR for several k, and a log-log regression over 64 modules recovers the exponent -b.
Honest simplifications
- Real stocks have age structure, spatial structure, noisy recruitment and delays; the Schaefer model has none of these and can understate collapse risk. Price and cost are constants here, with no market feedback.
- The learning rate is a fitted empirical regularity, not a law, and varies widely by technology. Savings are assumed constant for the whole horizon (no degradation, no tax, no inflation, no maintenance), and the retrofit does not change the harvest.
- Discounting treats a unit of money in the future as worth less today; the choice of d encodes how much weight is put on the future and is a value judgement, not a measured number. At d = 0 the NPV is a simple sum.
- The crates in the 3D view count cumulative harvest (one per 120 units); the cash bar shows the NPV (1 unit of height per 100 money units, red when negative). The flowing particles are illustrative.
What to try
- Move E from 0 to 50 and watch yield rise to MSY; push it to 80 and profit falls to about zero while the stock sits near 200 of 1000 (open access).
- Set E = 110: effort exceeds r/q = 100 and the stock decays towards zero.
- Raise the learning rate to 98 % and the discount rate to 12 %: the retrofit stops paying back inside the horizon.