V Formation Flight: Wake Vortices, Upwash and Power Saved by Migrating Geese

Geese fly in a V so each bird rides the upwash of the vortices shed by the birds ahead: change the spacing, flock size and bird size and see the induced power saved.

Switch to 2D

Presets

Playback

Parameters

Camera

Layers

Quality

Model check

The science

What is modelled

A flock of geese flies level at speed U. Every bird must carry its weight with its wings, and a wing that lifts also sheds a pair of trailing vortices that push the air behind it down between the vortices and up outside them. A bird that flies in the upwash of a bird ahead is partly carried by that rising air and needs less induced power. The page computes this field for every bird, shows it as a map of vertical air velocity at flight height, and adds up the savings for the chosen formation.

Equations

  • Elliptic lift: circulation Γ0 = 4 m g / (π ρ U b), trailing vortices (after roll-up) a distance b′ = (π/4) b apart, self-induced downwash w = Γ0/(2 b) and induced drag Di = 2 (m g)2 / (π ρ U2 b2).
  • Each bird is a horseshoe vortex: a bound segment of span b′ plus two semi-infinite trailing legs. The vertical velocity of a straight segment is the Biot-Savart integral w = (Γ/4πh)(cosθ1 − cosθ2), softened by a Vatistas core h2/(h2 + rc2) so that a wing tip inside a vortex does not give an infinite value.
  • A follower's induced drag is reduced by the load-weighted mean upwash across its span: Dj/Di,solo = 1 − mean(wup)/(Γ0/2b). The sum over all birds ahead gives the saving of each bird; a bird directly in a wake pays extra.
  • Power: P = (Di + Dprofile + Dbody) U with profile drag coefficient 0.014 on the wing area b2/AR and a body drag area 0.00813 m0.666 m2 with CD = 0.1 (Pennycuick-type constants). The wing-beat frequency uses the scaling f ∝ m3/8 g1/2 b−23/24 S−1/3 ρ−3/8.

Simplifications

  • This is the classical steady horseshoe model of formation flight: the wake does not decay or meander, birds hold their positions exactly, the wing-beat phase is ignored (a flapping bird sheds an undulating wake), and each bird is level in still air. The savings are therefore an upper bound; measured heart-rate and power savings of real flocks are much smaller than the ideal induced-power saving shown here.
  • Only the induced part of the power changes with position; profile and body drag are unchanged. The mass, span and aspect ratio sliders are independent, so combinations can be unrealistic.
  • The vortex core radius is a free parameter (default 0.1 span): the predicted optimum sideways spacing is sharp for a small core and flatter for a large one. The graph on the right shows how strongly the saving depends on getting the spacing right.
  • The wing-beat animation is slowed down and its shape is schematic; the flapping does not feed back on the aerodynamics.
Loading model...
Loading Blender model...
Induced-power saving of each bird
Mechanical power against flight speed
Mean saving against sideways spacing
Made with 🟠 Blender · Three.js