Renewable Harvest and Retrofit Economics (2D)

Side view of the stock, a phase line of growth against harvest, and the retrofit as a cost Gantt and a cash-flow timeline.

Switch to 3D

Readouts

Presets

Playback

Resource and retrofit

Left: side-view cross-section (Blender-rendered tank, crates and modules; the water level is the stock S). Right: the phase line, where the stock settles at the crossing of the green growth curve and the red harvest line.

Independent numerical checks

The science

Two textbook models share one site. A renewable stock (a managed fishery, forest or aquifer) regrows logistically and is harvested with effort E. An efficiency retrofit lowers the cost of each unit of effort; module prices follow a learning curve and the investment is valued with net present value, payback and internal rate of return. This is an educational sketch of established formulas, not business advice and not a model of any real organisation; money is in abstract units.

Equations. dS/dt = r S (1 - S/K) - q E S (Schaefer 1954). The phase line plots growth G(S) = r S (1 - S/K) and harvest H(S) = q E S; fixed points are where they cross, and the sign of G - H says whether S rises or falls. With qE < r the stable equilibrium is S* = K(1 - qE/r); the yield Y = qE S* peaks at MSY = rK/4 for E = r/(2q). Above E = r/q the stock decays to zero. K = 1000 and q = 0.004 are fixed. Profit π = p q E S - ceff E, maximal at EMEY = (r/2q)(1 - c/(pqK)), zero for free entry at EOA = (r/q)(1 - c/(pqK)) (Gordon 1954). Wright learning curve: the k-th module costs c0 k-b, b = -log2(LR); the Gantt strip lays the modules end to end so the total width is the investment I. Each module cuts the cost per unit effort by δ (capped at 80 %): A = min(0.8, nδ) c E per year; NPV = -I + A(1 - (1+d)-T)/d.

Checks in the page. RK4 against the exact solution of the stock equation (growth, critical and collapse cases), a 6,000-point scan against the closed forms for MSY, EMEY and EOA, NPV/payback/IRR against year-by-year sums, the learning-curve doubling ratio and log-log slope, and two new for this view: bisection roots of dS/dt (with their stability from the local slope, and G(K/2) = rK/4) and the Gantt bars tiling the investment exactly.

Honest simplifications. Real stocks have age structure, space, noisy recruitment and delays, which the Schaefer model lacks and so can understate collapse risk. Price and cost are constants (no market feedback). The learning rate is a fitted empirical regularity, not a law. Savings are constant over the horizon (no degradation, tax, inflation or maintenance) and the retrofit does not change the harvest. The discount rate encodes how much the future matters and is a value judgement. Crates count cumulative harvest (one per 120 units); the pipe particles are illustrative.

Tank, crate and module sprites: Blender (Cycles) renders of the 3D page's model.

Stock S over time (years)
Revenue, cost and profit against effort E
Module Gantt: width = cost of the k-th module (learning curve)
Discounted cash-flow timeline: yearly savings (bars) and cumulative cash (line)
Made with 🟠 Blender