Fizeau Toothed Wheel (3D)

Spin a toothed wheel until the returning light is eclipsed, then read the speed of light off the wheel speed.

Switch to 2D

Presets

Playback

Experiment: measure c

Wheel

Light path

Wheel speed

Observer and slow motion

Camera

Layers

Quality

Model check

The science

What you are looking at

The 3D scene is a Blender-built bench: a brass toothed wheel on an iron frame with a revolution counter, a lamp with a half-silvered plate, a collimating lens, an eyepiece telescope and a distant mirror on a stone pillar. The wheel carries N instanced teeth made from one Blender tooth. Pulses of light fly out and back in slow motion and meet the wheel at the phase the model says; the green or red dot is the beam on the rim. A lamp shines through a gap of a rotating toothed wheel, runs a long way to a distant mirror and comes back to the same spot on the wheel. Light needs a round-trip time tau; during that time the wheel turns. If the wheel has moved by a whole tooth pitch the returning light finds a gap again and the eyepiece is bright; if it has moved by half a pitch a tooth is in the way and the eyepiece goes dark (an eclipse). Reading the wheel speed at the first eclipse gives the speed of light without any clock faster than a counter on the axle. This is the arrangement Hippolyte Fizeau used in 1849 over a path of about 8.6 km; the model here is a teaching version of it, not a reproduction of his exact apparatus.

Equations used

  • Round-trip time tau = 2 L n / c0 with the exact SI value c0 = 299,792,458 m/s and the refractive index n of the path (air about 1.000293, a water-filled tube 1.333).
  • Pattern coordinate: one tooth pitch is the unit, so the wheel advances delta = N f tau = 2 N f L n / c0 pitches during the round trip (N teeth, f revolutions per second).
  • Gate: the wheel is open for the fraction g of every pitch. The time-averaged transmitted fraction of the lamp light is the overlap of the gate with itself shifted by delta: A(delta) = max(0, g - d) + max(0, g - (1 - d)), d = delta mod 1. For g = 0.5 this is a triangle wave, maximum g at integer delta, zero at half-integers.
  • Eclipses (g = 0.5): delta = k + 1/2 gives f_k = (2k + 1) c0 / (4 N L n), so the speed of light follows from c = 4 N L f_1 / n and, for a measured eclipse k, c = 4 N L f / (2k + 1) (in air this gives c0/n). Bright orders sit at f = k c0 / (2 N L n).
  • Smear of the returning image (width w in pitches) is a box average of A: T = [F(delta + w/2) - F(delta - w/2)] / w with F the exact antiderivative of A (F(1) = g^2). Wheel-speed jitter (relative sigma) is a Gaussian average over delta with spread delta * sigma. The displayed brightness is T / g: 100 % means the wheel stopped with a gap on the beam.

What every control does

  • Teeth N and gap fraction g set the gate. More teeth make the first eclipse come at a lower wheel speed (f_1 is proportional to 1/N); a gap fraction below 0.5 gives a wide dark plateau instead of a sharp minimum, above 0.5 the eclipse never gets fully dark (the dip only reaches (2g - 1)/g of the maximum brightness).
  • Path L and index n set tau. A longer path or a slower medium (n above 1) lowers every eclipse speed by the factor 1/(L n).
  • Wheel speed is the sum of a coarse and a fine slider; the fine one exists because eclipses are narrow (about 0.1 rev/s wide at 12 rev/s). The Speed ramp button sweeps from 0 to 3.5 f_1 and back.
  • Return-image smear rounds the eclipse minima (poor focusing); jitter blurs them in proportion to delta; detector noise is the eye/photometer noise added to the scan; the tachometer calibration error is a single random scale error on the speed reading (one draw per scan), which dominates the scatter of c.
  • Slow motion changes how many seconds one round trip lasts in the animation; it does not change any number, because every distance, speed and angle in the page keeps the same delta.
  • Experiment: a scan sweeps the wheel speed from 0 to 3.5 times the first eclipse speed, finds each eclipse centre from the two half-brightness crossings (this works for plateaus and for partial eclipses) and turns it into c. Repeating 60 scans shows the scatter.

Numerical checks (shown live on the page)

  • Brute-force scan of the gate model versus the closed form f_1 = c0 / (4 N L n).
  • Photon Monte Carlo with explicit wheel angles at departure and return (including blur and jitter) versus the closed-form brightness.
  • The mean of T over one period of delta must equal g^2, and an exact interval-arithmetic overlap must equal the triangle formula.

Simplifications, honestly

  • The light is treated as a beam of rays at a point on the rim; real beams have a finite width, diffraction at the gaps and lenses with aberrations. Their effect is lumped into the single smear parameter.
  • The wheel is an ideal two-state gate; the finite thickness of the teeth, vignetting and the time the beam needs to cross a gap are ignored.
  • The medium is lossless and non-dispersive; group and phase velocity are not distinguished (in air the difference is below 0.1 percent). Eye adaptation, flicker fusion and the personal judgement of a minimum are not modelled except as noise.
  • The scene is not to scale: the distant mirror is drawn 22 m away; the path length used in the formulae is the L slider (8.633 km by default). The Fizeau-style default matches the often quoted wheel with 720 teeth and a path of 8.633 km; the exact wheel speed of the historical first eclipse (about 12.6 rev/s, giving c of about 3.13e8 m/s, roughly 4 percent high) is quoted from memory and should be spot-checked. The model's own first eclipse for these numbers is 12.05 rev/s because it uses the true c.
Loading model...
Loading Blender model...
Eyepiece brightness versus wheel speed
Out and return gates over the tooth pattern
Eclipse speeds versus odd order 2k+1
Distribution of c from repeated scans
Made with 🟠 Blender · Three.js