Superconducting Resonator: Two-Level-System Saturation, Temperature and Ring-Down Time

A resonator chip on a copper stage: the meander glows with stored photons while surface TLS defects switch from absorbing (blue) to saturated (orange). Drag to orbit.

Switch to 2D
Controls

Presets

Parameters

Quality

Camera

Model checks

The science

Why a resonator loses photons. A superconducting microwave resonator stores energy in an electromagnetic mode with almost no conductor loss. At millikelvin temperatures its dominant loss is usually absorption by two-level systems (TLS), tunnelling defects in the amorphous oxides on the surfaces. At low drive and low temperature almost every TLS is in its ground state and can absorb a photon; a strong drive saturates them (they stop absorbing) and a warm chip thermally mixes them, so loss falls with power and with temperature. The loss tangent follows F tanδTLS = F tanδ0 tanh(hf0/2kBT) / (1 + n/nc)β, and the total internal quality factor is 1/Qi = F tanδTLS + 1/Qhp (McRae et al., arXiv:1909.07428, Eqs. 1-2; β is usually close to 0.5 there). Here n is the mean photon number and Qhp collects the power-independent high-power loss.

Ring-down. With coupling loss 1/Qc the stored photon number obeys dn/dt = -ω(1/Qc + 1/Qi(n,T)) n (integrated with RK4 in ln n): the decay starts fast and slows as the TLS saturate (n above nc) and ends at the low-power exponential. The notch spectrum S21 = 1 - (Ql/Qc)/(1 + 2iQl(f - f0)/f0) has FWHM f0/Ql = κ/2π.

Constants and what is illustrative. h/kB = 4.7992 x 10-11 K s is exact (SI 2019). A TLS loss tangent of the order of 10-3 for amorphous AlOx is reported by Pappas et al., IEEE Trans. Appl. Supercond. 21, 871 (2011) and 1.0 x 10-3 is quoted for a sputtered Al/Al2O3/Al trilayer in McRae et al. (arXiv:1909.07428); the filling factor F depends on the geometry (set by simulation), so the slider value of F tanδ0 (default 5 x 10-6) is a plausible order of magnitude, not a measured device. nc (default 10 photons), Qhp, Qc and f0 = 6 GHz are illustrative. Simplifications: one mode, a single saturation exponent, no quasiparticle loss, no TLS spectral diffusion, no frequency shift or Kerr effect, photon number treated as a continuous classical average. Checks: ring-down time from RK4 versus a Simpson integral of dn/(nκ); the small-signal ring-down rate versus the half-depth width of the |S21| dip (time-frequency duality); a Monte Carlo of thermally populated two-level systems versus tanh; and the decay rate at n = nc versus the 2-β saturation factor.

Loading model...
Loading Blender model...
-
-
Made with 🟠 Blender · Three.js