Niobium-Tantalum Separation

Three banks of Blender-built mixer-settlers separate Ta from Nb by solvent extraction; the layers show the concentration in every stage.

Switch to 2D

Presets

Playback

Feed

Oxide concentrations in the leach liquor.

Extraction section

Aqueous feed contacts fresh solvent.

Scrub section

Weaker acid washes Nb out of the loaded solvent.

Strip section

Almost acid-free water takes the Ta back into water.

Playback

Camera

Layers

Quality

Model checks

The science

The problem

Niobium and tantalum occur together in columbite-tantalite and pyrochlore ores and are chemically very alike. The classic industrial separation is liquid-liquid (solvent) extraction from an acid fluoride or sulphate liquor into an organic solvent such as MIBK, run in a bank of mixer-settlers: in each unit the two liquids are stirred together (mixer) and then allowed to separate (settler), and the two streams pass in opposite directions from unit to unit.

Model

  • Distribution ratio D = c_organic / c_aqueous depends on acidity. Here it follows illustrative Hill curves: D_Ta = 30 A^3/(A^3 + 2^3) and D_Nb = 3 A^4/(A^4 + 7.5^4), with A the acidity in M. They reproduce the qualitative trend (Ta extracts at moderate acidity, Nb only at high acidity) but are not measured data; real values depend on the fluoride level, solvent and temperature.
  • Separation factor beta = D_Ta / D_Nb: the bigger it is, the easier the split.
  • Counter-current cascade: with E = D x (O/A) the fraction transferred in N ideal stages is the Kremser equation f = (E^(N+1) - E) / (E^(N+1) - 1). The page computes every stage by the McCabe-Thiele recursion (equilibrium line y = D x plus the operating line from the mass balance A (x_(n-1) - x_n) = O (y_n - y_(n+1))) and checks it against that closed form.
  • Flowsheet: extraction (aqueous feed against fresh solvent) loads the solvent with Ta and some Nb; a scrub with weaker acid washes the co-extracted Nb back out, because D_Nb collapses at low acidity while D_Ta stays high; a strip with almost acid-free water finally pulls the Ta into a clean aqueous product. Purity is the Ta2O5 share of the product.

Honest simplifications

  • Ideal (equilibrium) stages, linear distribution (no loading limit, no competition between Nb and Ta for the solvent), constant flows, no emulsion or entrainment, and the scrub liquor is not recycled to the extraction as plants do. Organic and aqueous flows are taken as the same through the three sections, so only the ratios O/A are set.
  • Fluoride chemistry, HF handling, and safety are outside this model. It is an educational illustration of cascade stage-stepping, not a plant design tool.

Checks run in the page

(1) Recursion against the Kremser closed form for all nine cascades, plus the number of whole stages needed for 99 % extraction. (2) The single-stage separation factor against D_Ta / D_Nb. (3) The metal balance over raffinate, scrub liquor, product and spent solvent, and the end point of the McCabe-Thiele staircase.

What to try

  • Start with Balanced circuit, then raise the extraction acidity to 9 M: Nb extracts as well, beta collapses and the product purity falls (graph 2).
  • Choose Weak scrub (scrub acid 6 M): the scrub no longer removes Nb. Press Tune scrub acidity to find the best value.
  • Choose Too few stages and compare the staircase in graph 1 with Many stages. Switch the diagram to scrub or strip, and to Nb.
  • Lower the O/A ratio to 0.15: the extraction factor E drops below 1 and Ta cannot be recovered however many stages you add.
Loading model...
Loading Blender model...
McCabe-Thiele diagram of the selected section
Distribution ratios and separation factor vs acidity
Ta recovery and product purity vs extraction stages
Where each metal ends up
Made with 🟠 Blender · Three.js