loading...
Interface elevation along the tank (relative to the upper-layer thickness h1); hull in the middle, bow to the right
Drag against speed: steady total drag (solid), skin friction (dashed), tow pull (line) and the live state (dot with trail)
Press the button: the hull is driven at 12 constant speeds through the time-domain model with the current settings, the mean drag is measured and compared with the closed-form radiation formula.
running...
The science
Setup. Upper layer (fresh) density ρ1, thickness h1; lower layer (salt) ρ2, thickness h2; reduced gravity g′ = g (ρ2 - ρ1)/ρ2. Interface waves are slow because only the small density difference restores them. For long waves the speed is
c = sqrt( g′ h1 h2 / (h1 + h2) ) (typically 0.05 - 1 m/s, a few cm/s in a tank)
Dispersion. For wave number k the interface (with a rigid lid on top, which removes the fast surface waves) obeys
ω² = k (ρ2 - ρ1) g / ( ρ1 coth(k h1) + ρ2 coth(k h2) )
Short waves are slower, so cphase(k) falls from c at k = 0.
The hull as a forcing. The hull of length L and draught D is a depression d(x) = D cos²(π x/L) in the upper boundary. Solving Laplace's equation in both layers with kinematic and pressure conditions gives, for each k, a forced oscillator
η̇̇k + ωk² ηk = Mk ζ̇̇k, Mk = ρ1 / [ (ρ1 coth kh1 + ρ2 coth kh2) sinh kh1 ], ζ = -d(x - X(t))
The page integrates these oscillators for 200 or so wave numbers with a fourth-order Runge-Kutta scheme, together with the hull's equation of motion
(m + B Ma) dU/dt = Ftow - ½ ρ1 Cf S U|U| - B R
where R is the pressure on the hull bottom times its slope, R = ∫ p (dζ/dx) dx with p = -ρ1 ∂φ1/∂t at the lid, Ma is the added mass that the same integral contains (found analytically), B is the beam and the mass is m = Cb ρ1 L B D. Because the wave field is kept, the drag has memory: the hull can ride on its own wave train.
Closed form for steady speed. A hull moving at constant U radiates the wave whose phase speed equals U, ω(k0) = U k0 (the intersection of the dispersion curve with the straight line ω = U k, as for Cherenkov radiation). The drag per unit width is
R = ρ1 M(k0) d̂(k0)² k0³ U³ / [ 2 sinh(k0 h1) (U - cg) ], d̂(k) = ∫ d(x) e-ikx dx, R = 0 for U ≥ c
It is tiny at low speed, climbs steeply as U approaches c, and vanishes above c. If the pull is smaller than the hump, there is a stable speed below c where pull = drag: the ship is stuck. If the pull is larger, the hull accelerates through the hump (helped by inertia, so a pull a little below the peak can still succeed) and leaps to a supercritical speed.
Checks (run in the page). (1) the time-stepped period of the slowest mode against 2π/ω and its phase speed against the long-wave c; (2) energy conservation: the work done by the hull, ∫ U R dt, equals the gain in kinetic plus potential energy of the two layers, computed from the potentials, not from R; (3) the mean drag in the time domain against the closed form at two speeds; (4) doubling the resolution; (5) no radiation at U = 1.6 c; (6) the wavelength measured behind the hull (periodogram of the interface) against 2π/k0; (7) the speed at which the time-domain hull settles under a constant pull against the root of pull = drag.
Honest simplifications. Linear theory (amplitude small compared with h1; for draught above about a third of h1 real drag is lower than shown); rigid lid, i.e. no surface waves; two sharp layers instead of a smooth thermocline; strip theory: the hull spans the channel so the flow is two dimensional (a real ship in an open fjord also radiates sideways, which lowers the hump); a hull of fixed trim and draught; periodic channel of 80 hull lengths with a small damping so the old wake dies away; linear theory makes the drag peak very sharp just below c, where real drag is rounded off by nonlinearity and viscosity; the hump height scales with D². The Fram anecdote is historical; the tank numbers are illustrative.
The 3D picture is magnified in depth only when a layer would be unreadably deep (then the bottom is drawn shallower). Model by Blender (hull, carriage, tank frame with ruler; baked textures), physics and graphics by Three.js.