Prince Rupert's Cube Lab (3D)

A unit cube is drilled and an identical cube passes through. The shadow hexagon decides if it fits.

Switch to 2D

Presets

Playback

Tunnel direction

Direction of the drill in the cube frame. The cube turns so the tunnel always lies along the light beam.

Square tunnel

Twist, sideways offset and clearance of the square hole. The green outline on the screen means the cube fits.

Passing cube

How fast the red cube slides through.

Camera

Layers

Quality

Model checks

The science

The question

In 1693 John Wallis recorded a wager attributed to Prince Rupert of the Rhine: can a hole be cut through a cube so large that an identical cube passes through it? Surprisingly the answer is yes, and the hole is not a simple bore through the middle of a face. Here the cube has side 1 (a 10 cm block makes the numbers easy to feel).

1. Reduce a 3D question to a 2D one

Drill straight along a unit direction n. A straight tunnel of square cross-section leaves the cube in one piece exactly when the square lies inside the shadow of the cube projected along n (otherwise the tunnel walls would cut the block in two). The passing cube moves along n with a face square to n, so it passes iff a square of side 1 or more fits inside the shadow polygon. The shadow of a unit cube is the convex hull of the eight projected corners (u·p, v·p), a hexagon in general; its area is A(n) = |nx| + |ny| + |nz| (Cauchy).

2. The largest square in a convex polygon is a small linear programme

For a square of half-side h, centre c and twist ψ (axes e1=(cosψ, sinψ), e2=(−sinψ, cosψ)) and a polygon edge nk·x ≤ bk, the square stays inside iff nk·c + h(|nk·e1| + |nk·e2|) ≤ bk. Maximising h over (cx, cy, h) is a 3-variable LP. The page solves it exactly by enumerating tight triples of constraints, then maximises the side over the twist ψ by golden-section search, and over the direction (θ, φ) with a map plus a pattern search.

3. The two classical answers

Along the body diagonal the shadow is a regular hexagon of side a = √(2/3). The largest square inside it has side a(3 − √3) = 1.03528 (Prince Rupert's own solution). Pieter Nieuwland (1816) found the better value 3√2/4 = 1.06066 with tunnel direction (2, 2, −1)/3: a square with corners (3/4,0,0), (0,3/4,0), (1/4,1,1), (1,1/4,1) on the cube surface. The spare room is about 6 percent of the cube side, so the thinnest wall that remains is only a few millimetres on a 10 cm cube.

4. Wood left

The volume removed is the integral of the chord length of the cube along n over the square window, computed by midpoint quadrature. By Fubini's theorem the same integral over the whole shadow equals the volume of the cube, 1.

Model checks on this page

(1) The body-diagonal search against the closed form a(3 − √3). (2) Nieuwland's explicit surface square (all four sides 3√2/4), the numerical optimum along (2,2,−1)/3 and, after you press Search all directions, the global optimum. (3) For the current view, the hull area against |nx|+|ny|+|nz| and the Fubini integral against 1.

What to try

Choose Face-on: the shadow is exactly the unit square, so nothing can pass. Then Prince Rupert 1688 and Nieuwland 1816, and watch the largest square grow from 1.0353 to 1.0607. Drag Tilt and watch the map: only a small island of directions allows passage. Raise the clearance until the cube is stuck, or push the tunnel sideways until it leaves the shadow and the wall breaks.

Honest simplifications

Perfectly rigid cubes; the tunnel is a straight prism without taper; the passing cube travels along the tunnel axis with its faces square to it (the best way, since a tilted cube has a larger cross-section); the cube is assumed to hover while it is drilled. "Wood left" counts volume only and ignores the weakness of thin walls. Only tunnels with a square cross-section are explored; the cube can also be drilled with other shapes.

Loading model...
Loading Blender model...
Largest square versus twist (this direction)
Best square versus tilt (this azimuth)
Map of the best square over all directions
Shadow area versus tilt: hull of corners vs |nx|+|ny|+|nz|
Made with 🟠 Blender · Three.js