Polar Planimeter

2D twin of the 3D planimeter: the pole, the two arms, the stylus and the wheel on the paper, with the wheel reading converted to area and compared with the exact value.

Presets

Playback

Instrument

Arm lengths set the scale of the reading. A slipping wheel loses travel, so the area comes out too small by the same fraction.

Outline

Elbow side

To draw your own outline, press and drag on the paper (inside the paper rectangle and within the arms' reach), then press Close outline.

Model checks

The science

What is modelled

A polar planimeter has a fixed pole, a polar arm of length R, a hinge, and a tracer arm of length L ending in a stylus. A small wheel on the tracer arm rolls only in the direction perpendicular to the arm. When the stylus goes round a closed outline, the wheel's net rolling distance is proportional to the area inside it (Green's theorem in mechanical form).

Equations

  • Area from the wheel: A = L · swheel + corrections, where the corrections vanish for a closed outline when the pole is outside it.
  • Hinge position from the two arm lengths: intersection of two circles (elbow up or down).
  • Wheel travel per step: the displacement of the wheel point projected on the arm's normal.
  • Exact areas used in the checks: circle π r², ellipse π a b, rosette ½ ∫ r(t)² dt.

Checks run in the page

  • The circle and the ellipse: wheel area against the exact area (0.5 %).
  • The rosette with the elbow on each side: the reading must not depend on the elbow.

The checks use no wheel slip and the current arm lengths.

Honest simplifications

A perfectly rolling wheel (apart from the slip you add), an ideal rigid linkage, an outline approximated by 360 straight segments, and a pole outside the outline. A real planimeter also has a zero circle and a pole-inside correction constant.

What to try
  • Select Slipping wheel (8 %): the area from the wheel is 8 % smaller than the polygon area.
  • Change the tracer arm length: the numbers on the wheel change, but the area (arm length times wheel travel) stays the same.
  • Draw a lopsided loop of your own and compare the two area readings.
Area from the wheel as the outline is traced
Wheel travel: ideal and observed
Area error against wheel slip
Wheel area and polygon area for four outlines
Made with 🤖 ChatGPT