Boy's Surface Lab (2D)

The unit disk with glued opposite rim points, and the self-crossing surface it becomes. Willmore energy 12 pi, Euler characteristic 1.

Switch to 3D

Presets

Playback

View and patch

How much of the disk is drawn, and the viewing angles. Dragging the shaded view changes the same two angles.

Layers

Model checks

The science

What this surface is

The real projective plane RP2 (a sphere with every pair of opposite points glued together) cannot sit in 3D space without crossing itself. Werner Boy found in 1901 that it can be immersed in space, with a single triple point and a looping curve of self-crossings. Boy's surface is that immersion. It has only one side, like a Möbius strip, and no boundary.

1. The Bryant-Kusner (Apery) formula

For a complex number w in the closed unit disk put D = w6 + √5 w3 − 1, g1 = −(3/2) Im[w(1 − w4)/D], g2 = −(3/2) Re[w(1 + w4)/D], g3 = Im[(1 + w6)/D] − 1/2. The surface point is X(w) = (g1, g2, g3) / (g12 + g22 + g32), the inversion in the unit sphere of a minimal surface with three ends. On the boundary circle X(w) = X(−w), so the disk closes up into RP2. The three zeros of D inside the disk, at |w| = ((3 − √5)/2)1/3 = 0.7256 and angles 0, 120 and 240 degrees, all map to the origin: that is the triple point.

2. Willmore energy

The Willmore energy is W = ∫ H2 dA with H = (κ1 + κ2)/2. A round sphere has W = 4π. A point where k sheets meet forces W ≥ 4πk (Li and Yau), so any immersed RP2 with a triple point has W ≥ 12π. The Bryant-Kusner Boy surface attains exactly 12π and is the conjectured minimiser (Kusner) among immersions of the projective plane. Here H and the area element come from central differences of the formula, integrated by midpoint quadrature in polar coordinates on the disk.

3. Gauss-Bonnet and the Euler characteristic

For any closed surface ∫ K dA = 2π χ. For the projective plane χ = 1, so the total Gaussian curvature of the parametrised surface must be 2π, even though the surface crosses itself in space (the integral is over the abstract disk, not over the picture). The page also counts V − E + F on the actual triangle mesh after gluing opposite boundary vertices, which gives 1.

Model checks on this page

(1) The quadrature value of the Willmore energy against 12π. (2) The quadrature value of ∫ K dA against 2π. (3) The glued-mesh Euler characteristic, the boundary identification X(w) = X(−w) to machine precision, and the three poles landing on the origin.

What to try

Press Grow the surface and watch the patch spread from the middle of the disk: the triple point does not exist until the radius passes 0.7256, when the three outer sheets arrive. Use Mean curvature to see where bending is concentrated, and Slice through the triple point to look inside. Rotate with the mouse. In the disk map (graph 4) the gold rim is glued to itself with a half turn.

Honest simplifications

The picture is the specific Bryant-Kusner immersion, a smooth member of Boy's family; other immersions exist. The mesh is finite (96 rings by 192 spokes, with a tiny hole at the very centre), and the sum of squares of curvature is accurate to about 0.01 percent. The sculpture is drawn without its double-point curve highlighted: the self-intersection is visible only as where sheets pass through each other. The surface is one-sided, so the shading of its two faces is a rendering convention.

What to try

Press Grow the surface and watch the patch spread from the middle of the disk; the three white dots on the disk are the preimages of the triple point, and they only count once the dashed circle passes them (r = 0.7256). Switch the colour to Mean curvature and compare the shaded view with the disk map. Hover over the gold rim of the disk: the probe jumps to the opposite point of the same surface point and the gap readout shows zero. Drag the shaded view to turn the surface, and use the Three-fold symmetry lobes preset to look straight down the axis.

Willmore energy so far versus disk radius
Total Gaussian curvature so far (Gauss-Bonnet)
Area of the patch versus disk radius
Where the bending energy sits: Willmore density dW/dr