Genetic drift and selection: gene-pool jars

Twelve marble jars resample themselves every generation: drift, selection, mutation and migration.

Switch to 2D

Presets

Playback

Population

Run

Camera

Layers

Quality

Model check

The science

What is modelled

One gene with two alleles, A (red marbles) and a (blue marbles), in a population of N diploid individuals, so 2N gene copies. Each jar is a gene pool. In every generation the next pool is drawn at random, with replacement, from the parents, after any selection, mutation or migration. That random draw is genetic drift: allele frequencies wander and eventually one allele is lost and the other fixed, even with no selection at all. The jars are 12 independent runs from the same start; the graphs use 200 runs.

Equations

  • Fitness AA : Aa : aa = 1 + s : 1 + hs : 1 gives the mean fitness w̄ = p²(1+s) + 2pq(1+hs) + q² and the post-selection frequency p' = [p²(1+s) + pq(1+hs)] / w̄.
  • Mutation u = v each way and migration at rate m from a source with frequency pm: p'' = (1 − m)[p'(1 − u) + (1 − p')u] + m pm.
  • Sampling: the next count of A copies is Binomial(2N, p''), variance p(1 − p)/2N per generation.
  • Neutral heterozygosity decays as Ht = H0 (1 − 1/2N)t; the chance that a neutral allele eventually fixes equals its starting frequency; the mean time to fixation (given that it fixes) is T = −4N p ln p / (1 − p) generations.
  • Additive selection (h = 1/2): Kimura's fixation probability u(p) = (1 − e−2Nsp)/(1 − e−2Ns) (a diffusion approximation; with these fitnesses each copy of A has advantage s/2). Selection beats drift when 2N|s| is well above 1.
  • Heterozygote advantage (h > 1, s > 0) keeps both alleles at p* = h/(2h − 1) in a large population.

Checks run in the page (seeded Monte Carlo, error bars shown)

  • Neutral heterozygosity after 30 generations against H0(1 − 1/2N)t.
  • Neutral fixation probability against the starting frequency.
  • Fixation probability with selection against Kimura's formula.
  • Iterating the deterministic map for heterozygote advantage against h/(2h − 1).

Honest simplifications

  • Constant population size, random mating, discrete non-overlapping generations, one locus, no linkage. The effective size is taken equal to N.
  • Kimura's formula is an approximation for large N and small s; the check allows a 0.02 tolerance for that.
  • The marbles are a picture of the 2N gene copies; their positions are only a pile, not part of the model.

What to try

  • "Neutral drift, small population" loses variation within about 40 generations; "large population" takes hundreds. Watch H fall along the dashed line.
  • "Rare beneficial mutant": most runs lose the allele while the lucky ones sweep to fixation. About 2s of them win.
  • "Heterozygote advantage" keeps both colours in every jar.
Loading model...
Loading Blender model...
Allele frequency in the 12 jars
Frequency across 200 runs
Heterozygosity (drift removes variation)
Made with 🟠 Blender · Three.js