3D Swimming Stroke: Hand Path, Drag and Lift in Front Crawl

Race a straight pull against an S-pull in two lanes: quasi-steady drag and lift on the hand, momentum balance for the swimmer, and the surprising efficiency curve.

Switch to 2D

Presets

Playback

Parameters

Camera

Layers

Quality

Model check

The science

The question. Coaches teach front-crawl swimmers to pull the hand along a wavy path (an "S-pull": out, in, out) rather than straight back. Is that faster? This page gives the hand the same fore-and-aft travel and the same pull time in both lanes and changes only the sideways and vertical sweep, so any difference comes from the hand path alone.

Model. The hand plus forearm is one flat paddle of effective area A = 0.055 m2. In the water frame the paddle moves with vw = vhand relative to the body + U z-hat, where U is the swimmer's forward speed, so a hand that is swept back at 2 m/s while the body travels forward at 1.7 m/s only moves through the water at 0.3 m/s ("slip"). Quasi-steady flat-plate forces: F = ½ rho A vw2 [ CD (-v-hat) + CL p-hat ] with CD = 1.1 sin2a and CL = 1.1 sin a cos a (equivalent to a normal-force coefficient 1.1 sin a), a being the angle between the hand plane and the flow, and p-hat the part of "forward" that is perpendicular to the flow, i.e. the swimmer pitches the hand so the lift points forward. The swimmer's speed follows from momentum balance with two arms 180 degrees out of phase: M dU/dt = Fz,left + Fz,right - ½ rho CdA U2 with M = 75 kg and body drag area CdA = 0.036 m2 (about 41 N at 1.5 m/s). The Froude efficiency is the useful power (mean thrust times mean speed) divided by the power the arms spend against the water, -F . vhand relative to body. The legs only kick for show.

What it shows, and a surprise. More sweep makes the hand travel faster through the water and use lift, so the swimmer goes faster, but the arms also do far more work, and the Froude efficiency does not keep rising: in this model it peaks at a modest sweep and falls for large sweeps. So the claim that the S-pull is simply "more efficient" is not what the physics gives; the S-pull is a way to get more speed from a given fore-and-aft arm travel at the price of more arm power. The curves on the right show speed and efficiency against the sweep for your current pitch and stroke rate.

Honest simplifications. Quasi-steady forces ignore added mass, unsteady vortex shedding (hand accelerations are large, so real forces differ by tens of percent), the interaction of the two hands, the forearm as a separate blade, body roll, undulation, the kick and the breathing cycle. The flat-plate coefficients are textbook order-of-magnitude values; measured hand coefficients (Schleihauf and others) have maximum drag about 1.0 to 1.2 and maximum lift about 0.5 to 0.6, which this plate roughly reproduces. The hand pitch is a free parameter, not a controller. Mass, hand area and body drag are assumed round values for an adult male sprinter, and the swimmer starts at 0.5 m/s rather than from a dive. Paths are stylised, not motion-capture data.

Checks. (1) coasting without arms against the closed form U0/(1 + kU0t); (2) the hand force of a straight pull against the pure-drag formula, and the drag-plus-lift vector of a sweeping pull against the flat-plate normal-force form; (3) momentum balance over twelve seconds of strokes, MΔU against the integral of thrust minus drag; (4) a plausibility range for the default stroke against published sprint speeds, distances per cycle and Froude efficiencies.

Loading model...
Loading Blender model...
Swimmer speed over the last eight cycles
Mean speed against S-pull sweep
Froude efficiency against S-pull sweep
Made with 🟠 Blender · Three.js