Whirlpool - 2D plan view and surface profile

Water circling a drain speeds up toward the centre; the pressure drop needed for that curved flow pulls the free surface into a funnel that fades as viscosity spreads the vortex core.

Switch to 3D

Presets

Playback

Parameters

Model checks

The science

Velocity profile

A potential (irrotational) vortex has vθ = Γ / (2π r), which diverges at the centre. Real fluid has a viscous core. The Lamb-Oseen vortex is the exact solution of the Navier-Stokes equations for a line vortex spreading by viscosity: vθ = Γ / (2π r) · (1 - exp(-r2/rc2)) with core radius rc2 = rc02 + 4 ν t. The Rankine vortex (solid-body rotation inside rc, potential outside) is the simple cartoon of it. The circulation Γ is the integral of the vorticity ω = Γ / (π rc2) exp(-r2/rc2) over the plane.

The funnel

Fluid moving on circles needs a radial pressure gradient dp/dr = ρ vθ2 / r. At the free surface the pressure is atmospheric, so the surface drops by Δz(r) = ∫r∞ vθ2 / (g r') dr'. For the Lamb-Oseen vortex the centre dip is exactly Δz(0) = Γ2 ln 2 / (4π2 g rc2); for the Rankine vortex it is Γ2 / (4π2 g rc2). As viscosity widens the core the dip decays like 1/rc2.

Checks

(1) The radial diffusion equation for the vorticity is solved by finite differences and compared with the exact Gaussian core growth; (2) the dip integral is evaluated numerically and compared with the closed form with ln 2; (3) the circulation is recovered by integrating the vorticity of the profile.

Honest simplifications: a two-dimensional line vortex of effectively infinite depth, a flat far-field level, no radial inflow into the drain (a real bathtub vortex is a Burgers vortex with axial suction), no surface-tension or air-core effects, and an eddy viscosity chosen by the slider rather than computed. The dip is clipped on screen at the drain depth.

What to try
  • Press Bathtub drain and then Tornado-like vortex: the dip grows with the square of the circulation.
  • Increase viscosity and watch the core radius grow while the dip decays in the right graph.
  • Compare Lamb-Oseen with Rankine in the left graph: they agree outside the core but not near the axis.
  • Lower gravity (Moon) and see the same vortex dig a deeper funnel.
Tangential velocity against radius
Free-surface dip against radius (dashed: Rankine)
Central dip and core radius against time