Loading 3D engine...
Flat stone beam: bending
Parabolic arch: compression
Arch vs flat roof, same 10 m span
Stone resists compression about 20 to 50 times better than tension. A flat beam carries load by bending and must be very deep; an arch turns the same load into compression and can be thin, but it pushes sideways on its walls.
Flat beamArch
Thickness needed
Stone per m of strip
Peak stress
Horizontal push on walls
Mid-span sag (real)-
tensioncompressionthrust line / flow
Self-checks (live)
The science

Per 1 m strip of roof, span L = 10 m, stone weight 24 kN/m3, allowable tension (modulus of rupture) 2 MPa, allowable compression 10 MPa, Young's modulus 30 GPa. These are rounded, illustrative values for sound stone masonry.

Flat beam (simply supported, Euler-Bernoulli). Self-weight grows with depth h, so h is solved, not guessed:

w  = q + g*h
M  = w L^2 / 8
sigma = 6 M / h^2 <= sigma_t
=> sigma_t h^2 - 0.75 g L^2 h - 0.75 q L^2 = 0
sag = 5 w L^4 / (384 E I),  I = h^3/12

Even with q = 0 the stone beam needs about 0.9 m of depth just to carry itself, which is why unreinforced stone never spanned 10 m flat. The sag drawn is multiplied by a stated factor; the real value is shown in the table.

Arch. A parabola y = 4 f x (L - x) / L^2 is the exact funicular (zero bending) shape for load that is uniform per horizontal metre:

H = w L^2 / (8 f)       horizontal thrust
V = w L / 2             vertical reaction
N_max = sqrt(H^2 + V^2) at the springing
w = q + g t k           (k = arc length / span)
Half-span live load: M = q L^2 / 64 (three-hinged parabolic arch)
sigma = N_max / t + 6 M / t^2 <= sigma_c

t is found by bisection, with a practical minimum of 0.12 m. The thrust line stays inside the middle third of the section when e = M/N <= t/6; the page reports whether that holds.

Honest limits. Self-weight of the arch is treated as uniform per horizontal metre (slightly wrong for steep sections); buckling, wind, foundation movement and joint sliding are ignored; real arches are checked with thrust-line limit analysis (Heyman). The walls must resist H, so the arch also needs buttresses or ties: the thrust is the price of its thinness. Real snow load is about 1 to 3 kN/m2; the slider goes higher to show the trend.

Drag to orbit, scroll or pinch to zoom
Made with 🟠 Blender · Three.js