Stone arch: thrust line, hinges and minimum thickness

A Blender-built stone bridge whose ring you can thicken, thin, load and let go: the thrust line says whether it stands.

Switch to 2D

Presets

Playback

Arch geometry and load

Camera

Layers

Quality

Model check

The science

What you are looking at

A 10 m span stone arch (3 m wide) on two ashlar abutments over a river. The site, stone texture and iron block are Blender models; the voussoirs are built live from the arch geometry you choose, so the stones you see are exactly the stones the statics weigh.

Statics: the thrust line

Masonry carries load in compression only. Following Heyman's limit analysis we assume infinite compressive strength, no tension and no sliding. The weights of the voussoirs (and the point load) form a funicular polygon called the thrust line: yT(x) = yL + (yR − yL)·x/S + M0(x)/H, where M0 is the simple-beam bending moment of the loads and H the horizontal thrust. The arch is statically indeterminate: any (yL, yR, H) whose line stays inside every joint is a possible state of equilibrium, and by the safe theorem the arch then stands. Because the conditions are linear in (yL, yR, 1/H), a small linear programme finds the line with the biggest margin and the range of admissible H.

Geometric safety factor

The minimum thickness tmin is found by bisection (ring weight recomputed each time). The factor shown is t / tmin. A semicircular arch of uniform thickness has tmin/R = 0.1075 (Heyman); an inverted catenary of uniform thickness is its own thrust line, so it is stable at any thickness. Cracks (hinges, yellow) open where the line touches the intrados or extrados; the old "middle third" rule (green band) is the stricter condition that the whole joint stays in compression.

Honest simplifications

Plane (2D) statics of a barrel vault: no spandrel fill, no parapet, no abutment movement, no sliding, no crushing failure. The stress figure assumes a linear stress block on the part of the joint in contact and uses the total joint force; real stone stresses are higher at hinges. Stone density 2400 kg/m³. The falling-stone animation after "Remove the centring" is illustrative (rigid blocks falling onto the floor), not a dynamic contact simulation. Voussoirs are cut radially to the centre-line.

Checks on this page

(1) Heyman's t/R = 0.1075 benchmark. (2) The catenary benchmark. (3) 40000 random thrust lines scored by a separate evaluator never beat the optimiser. (4) Volume of the drawn voussoir meshes equals the weighed polygon area times width.

Loading model...
Loading Blender model...
Thrust line inside the ring (elevation)
Eccentricity of the thrust at each joint
Peak stone stress at each joint
Minimum thickness vs rise (current shape and load)
Made with 🟠 Blender · Three.js