Carbon Crossover Lab

2D companion of the embodied-versus-operational carbon crossover: two buildings, one cumulative ledger.

Switch to 3D

Presets

Playback

Apparatus

Model checks

The science

What is modelled

Every building has a one-off carbon cost to make the materials and build it (embodied carbon) and a yearly cost to heat, cool and light it (operational carbon). If one building is cheaper to build but dearer to run, the cumulative totals cross at some year, or never within the life of the building.

Equations

  • Grid factor q = 1 − d per year; operational emission in year k is o qk.
  • Cumulative operation S(t) = (1 − qt) / (−ln q), which tends to t when the grid stays dirty.
  • Total C(t) = E + o S(t); the timber building carries the credit Et − stored carbon.
  • Crossover where S* = (Ec − Et) / (ot − oc), at t* = ln(1 − S* (−ln q)) / ln q; if S* exceeds the limit 1/(−ln q) the curves never meet.

Checks run in the page

  • Analytic crossover against bisection.
  • Closed-form operation against year-by-year bookkeeping.
  • The constant-grid limit.
  • The derivative of the crossover year against the embodied carbon.
  • The end-of-life difference of the two totals.

Honest simplifications

The numbers are round illustrative values per square metre, not an assessment of any real building. There is no maintenance, replacement, end-of-life or discounting, and the storage credit is simply deducted. A real life-cycle assessment uses standard modules and measured data.

What to try
  • Press Fossil grid forever and Clean grid soon and compare the crossover years.
  • Press Timber thermal penalty and watch the crossover come much earlier.
  • Press With storage credit: timber starts so far ahead that the curves may never meet in the lifetime.
Cumulative carbon
Difference between the buildings
Crossover against grid decarbonisation
Crossover against concrete embodied carbon