Atmospheric Lightning: Charge Separation Modeling

Thundercloud charging, electric field vs breakdown threshold, stepped leader, attachment and return stroke over a Blender-modelled plain.

Presets

Playback

Charge separation

Breakdown

Stepped leader and attachment

Return stroke and observer

Camera

Layers

Quality

Model check

The science

Charge separation

In a cumulonimbus, graupel (soft hail) falls through a rising cloud of small ice crystals and supercooled droplets. Each rebounding collision transfers charge; above the reversal temperature (about -15 C) the graupel gains negative charge, below it positive. Rising crystals carry the opposite sign upwards, so the cloud becomes a tripole: a main negative layer near -15 C, a positive layer above and a small positive pocket near the 0 C level. The simulation uses the order-of-magnitude balance dQ/dt = Isep - Q/τ with Isep ≈ 1 A (w/15 m/s)(LWC/1.5 g m-3), so the charge saturates at Qeq = Isep τ. Layer altitudes follow the temperature profile T(z) = Tg - 6.5 K/km z.

Electric field of the charged layers

Each layer is a uniformly charged horizontal disc of radius R, with the conducting ground handled by image charges -q at -h. On the axis the field and potential are exact: Ez = (σ/2ε0)[sgn(dz) - dz/√(dz²+R²)], φ = (σ/2ε0)[√(dz²+R²) - |dz|], σ = q/πR². Off the axis (field lines, field mill) each disc is sampled by rings of point charges E = k q r / r³. A positive Ez points up; under a negative cloud the ground field reverses from the fair-weather -0.1 kV/m to several kV/m.

Breakdown threshold

Dry air breaks down at Ek ≈ 2.6 MV/m · ρ/ρ0 (density falls as e-z/8.4 km), a positive streamer can propagate at ≈0.44 MV/m · ρ/ρ0 and relativistic runaway electrons appear above ≈0.28 MV/m · ρ/ρ0. Measured fields inside storms are only 100-400 kV/m, about ten times below Ek. The model therefore multiplies the ambient field by an enhancement factor β (raindrops, ice crystals and streamer seeds concentrate the field locally): a flash starts when max(β|Ez|/Ek) ≥ 1 below the negative layer. How cloud lightning is really initiated is still an open research question.

Stepped leader and attachment

The negative leader advances in steps of about 50 m, pausing between steps, at a mean speed of 105-106 m/s, and branches. Here it is a biased random walk (preferred direction downwards and towards nearby grounded objects, random turning set by the tortuosity), and the line charge density λ gives the charge it lowers: QL = λ L. The prospective peak current grows with that charge, Ip = 10.6 QL0.7 (kA, C; Cooray), and the striking distance is rs = 10 Ip0.65 (m, kA). Following the rolling-sphere method used in lightning-protection standards, the leader attaches to the first grounded object (or the ground) that comes within rs of its tip; a short upward connecting leader then rises from that object. A lightning rod works because it is the first thing the sphere touches.

Return stroke, energy, thunder

When the channel connects, a return-stroke wave runs up it at about one third of the speed of light, discharging the channel. Its current is modelled with the Heidler function i(t) = (I0/η) (t/τ1)n/(1+(t/τ1)n) e-t/τ2 (first stroke 1.8 / 95 us, n = 10; subsequent strokes 0.25 / 2.5 us). The part of QL not carried by the impulsive current is attributed to continuing current. The electrostatic energy released is estimated as W ≈ ½ QL Δφ with Δφ the potential of the channel origin from the model. Heating the channel to about 30 000 K launches a shock wave whose relaxation radius is R0 = √(W/L / p0); the dominant thunder frequency is f ≈ cs/(2.63 R0) (Few, 1969), and the flash-to-bang delay is d / cs with cs = 331.3 √(1 + T/273.15) m/s (about 3 s per km).

Honest simplifications

A uniformly charged thin disc makes the field jump by σ/ε0 across its plane, which is why the on-axis curve has steps at the layer altitudes; a real layer is a few hundred metres thick and smoother. Real charge regions are irregular, change with microphysics and drift in the wind; the discs, a single leader origin and the constant current Isep are a teaching model. Leader growth uses a random walk, not a solution of Laplace's equation (the 2D companion does solve it). The terrain relief (up to 11 m on the knoll) is ignored in the cloud field. Flash timing is slowed down for display; the physical durations are shown in the readouts (leader tens of ms, return stroke tens of us). No lightning-safety advice is intended: go indoors when thunder is audible.

Model checks: ring-sampled field vs the exact disc formula; ground equipotential and ∫E dz = Δφ; Gauss law for the ground-induced charge; Heidler peak and charge by two quadratures.

Loading model...
Loading Blender model...
Electric field on the cloud axis vs breakdown thresholds
Charge Qn and ground field history (field mill)
Return-stroke current waveform (Heidler)
Peak current and striking distance vs leader charge
Made with 🟠 Blender · Three.js