Green Roof vs Bare Roof: Hydrographs and Storage (2D)

Same storm, two roofs: a bare roof passes the rain straight to the pipe, a green roof first fills its substrate and then delays the excess.

Switch to 3D
Controls

Presets

Parameters

Model checks

The science

Retention and detention. A green roof does two jobs. Retention: the substrate stores plant-available water and keeps it until plants evaporate it. Detention: once the substrate is full, the excess rain does not leave at once but trickles through the drainage layer and gutters, which lengthens and flattens the outflow peak. Here the substrate store is Smax = c d with c = 2.0 mm of plant-available water per cm of substrate depth d, and the part already filled is set by the ‘already filled’ slider.

Model. Rain intensity is i(t) = (P/D)[(1-b) + b·tri(t/D)] with total depth P over duration D. While S < Smax all rain is retained. Afterwards the excess e(t) enters a linear reservoir, dG/dt = e - G/K, outflow q = G/K, with K = 10 + 4d minutes (a thicker build-up delays the water more). A bare roof of the same area is the same reservoir with Kc = 3 min and no store. For steady rain the answer is exact: q(t) = i0(1 - e-(t - t0)/K) after the store fills at t0 = (Smax - S0)/i0. The scheme advances each reservoir with the exact exponential per time step, so the volume bookkeeping is exact.

What the numbers mean. Small storms (below the free storage) are retained completely; large storms are only delayed and trimmed, because the substrate is full before the peak. Substrate depth matters most for frequent, small events; a saturated roof (after a wet week) behaves almost like a bare roof with a slower pipe.

Simplifications. Constant storage per cm, no evapotranspiration during the storm, no limit on infiltration rate, a single linear drainage reservoir, flat roof, uniform rain. Real roofs have a plant- and season-dependent capacity (typically 25 to 60 % annual retention for thin extensive systems). Checks: mass balance; trapezoid integral of the hydrograph against the analytic runoff volume; zero outflow below the free storage; the steady-rain closed form; the exponential recession constant; and an independent RK4 integration of the continuous equations.

-
-