Paper Chromatography

2D twin of the 3D page: watch a marker spot split into its dyes as the solvent climbs, and read the Rf values off an enlarged strip.

Switch to 3D

Presets

Playback

Paper and bands

Pore size sets the speed; plate height and spot size set the band width.

Marker and solvent

Model checks

The science

What is modelled

A felt-tip ink spot is placed on a pencil line near the bottom of a paper strip hanging in a beaker with a little solvent. The solvent climbs the strip through the paper pores by capillary action and carries the dyes with it. A dye that sticks to the cellulose fibres spends more time standing still, so it travels a smaller fraction of the solvent front. The page follows the front, the position and the width of each dye band, and paints the result on the strip.

Equations

  • Solvent front, Poiseuille flow through pores of radius r with tortuosity τ = 2: dh/dt = r² / (8 μ τ² h) · (2 γ cosθ / r - ρ g h). At early times this is the Washburn law h² = (r γ cosθ / (2 μ τ²)) t; at late times the front stops at the Jurin height h∞ = 2 γ cosθ / (ρ g r). The exact implicit solution is B t = -h∞ ln(1 - h/h∞) - h.
  • Retention: a dye in equilibrium between mobile solvent and stationary paper has a retention factor k and moves at Rf = 1 / (1 + k) of the distance from the baseline to the front. The polarity of the solvent changes k as k = k0 exp(-s (P - 0.75)): a more polar solvent moves the strongly polar blue dye further.
  • Bands are Gaussians of constant mass with σ² = σ0² + H d (spot size plus diffusion and uneven flow along the way); two bands are separated when Rs = (d2 - d1) / (2 (σ1 + σ2)) ≥ 1.5.

Simplifications

  • The pore radius, tortuosity, contact angle (25 degrees), plate height and the dye constants k0, s are illustrative values chosen to give realistic run times (about 10 minutes for 12 cm in water) and Rf values between 0.2 and 0.9; they are not data for a particular paper or pen. Real markers contain other dyes and the bands can streak.
  • The flow is treated as a single sharp front with no evaporation, no solvent-composition gradient (a mixed solvent can separate into its own bands) and a linear isotherm; dyes are assumed not to interact with each other.

Numerical checks

Four checks run when the page loads (see Model check): the numerical front against the exact implicit solution, the Washburn law and the Jurin height; band mass and Rf = 1/(1 + k) from the numerical moments; the valley-to-peak ratio of two Gaussians 4 sigma apart against the closed form behind Rs; and the Blender strip and pencil-line dimensions against the geometry used in the model.

What to try
  • Start with the black marker in water and watch the single spot split: the blue dye sticks to the paper (small Rf), the yellow one travels almost with the front.
  • Switch to acetone: the solvent polarity changes every Rf and the bands crowd together; the third graph shows Rf against polarity.
  • Raise the plate height or the spot radius: the bands smear and the resolution Rs drops below 1.5.
Dye concentration along the strip
Solvent front against time
Retention factor against solvent polarity
Made with 🟠 Blender