Dutch Roll and Spiral Mode Lab (3D)

A Blender light aircraft flies the lateral-directional equations: nose wag with rocking wings, the slow spiral, and what dihedral, fin size and a yaw damper do to them.

Switch to 2D

Presets

Playback

Aircraft geometry and inertia

Dihedral and fin area change the derivatives; the inertias set how fast the aircraft responds.

Yaw damper

Feeds yaw rate back to the rudder.

Flight condition

Airspeed and altitude set the dynamic pressure and the lift coefficient.

Pilot inputs and turbulence

Held control deflections, sideways gusts, and the size of the drawn angles.

Camera

Layers

Quality

Model checks

The science

Three motions, one aircraft

Disturb an aircraft sideways and its lateral-directional response splits into three natural motions. The Dutch roll is a fast coupled wag: the nose yaws left and right while the wings roll in step, a few seconds per cycle (name borrowed from the rhythm of a skater). The roll subsidence is a very fast, heavily damped roll that dies out in a fraction of a second. The spiral mode is a slow, non-oscillating drift: a small bank makes the aircraft turn, the turn tightens the bank, and either the bank fades over tens of seconds or it grows into a spiral dive. Designers must trade them off: more dihedral helps the spiral and hurts the Dutch roll damping.

Equations (small perturbations, stability axes)

State x = [sideslip beta, roll rate p, yaw rate r, bank phi]. With V the true airspeed:

beta' = Y_b beta + (g/V) phi - r + Y_dr dr
p' = L_b beta + L_p p + L_r r + L_da da
r' = N_b beta + N_p p + N_r r + N_da da + N_dr dr
phi' = p

The dimensional derivatives come from dynamic pressure q = rho V^2 / 2, wing area S, span b, mass m: Y_b = q S CY_b / (m V), L_b = q S b Cl_b / Ixx (dihedral effect, negative), N_b = q S b Cn_b / Izz (weathercock stability from the fin, positive), L_p = q S b^2 Cl_p / (2 V Ixx) (roll damping), N_r = q S b^2 Cn_r / (2 V Izz) (yaw damping). The lift coefficient CL = m g / (q S) at each speed sets the cross terms Cl_r = 0.22 CL and Cn_p = -0.07 CL. The fin gives Cn_b,fin = a_v Sv lv / (S b) and Cn_r,fin = -2 (lv/b) Cn_b,fin with lift-curve slope a_v = 2.6 per radian, tail arm lv = 4.6 m. Dihedral: Cl_b = -0.065 - 0.0134 Gamma (Gamma in degrees).

The modes from the eigenvalues

The 4 x 4 matrix A has characteristic polynomial s^4 + a1 s^3 + a2 s^2 + a3 s + a4 = 0. The page finds its four roots (Durand-Kerner iteration with Newton polishing) and classifies them: a complex pair is the Dutch roll with omega_n = |s| and zeta = -Re(s)/|s|; the most negative real root is the roll subsidence (time constant 1/|s|); the smallest real root is the spiral (it doubles or halves in ln 2 / |s| seconds). The Routh-Hurwitz test says all four are stable exactly when a1..a4 > 0 and a1 a2 a3 - a3^2 - a1^2 a4 > 0. Because phi' = p, the determinant simplifies to det A = (g/V)(L_b N_r - L_r N_b), so the classical spiral-stability criterion is L_b N_r > L_r N_b.

Textbook approximations (shown next to the exact roots)

Dutch roll with the roll degree of freedom frozen: omega_n^2 = N_b + Y_b N_r, 2 zeta omega_n = -(Y_b + N_r). Roll subsidence: lambda = L_p. Spiral: set all derivatives to zero and solve the three remaining linear equations for p/phi. The graph of damping ratio against yaw-damper gain draws both the exact and approximate curves.

Yaw damper

The damper commands rudder proportional to yaw rate, dr = -Kr r, which adds -N_dr Kr to N_r. It raises the Dutch-roll damping ratio while leaving the roll subsidence nearly untouched; the pole map shows the Dutch-roll pair moving left as the gain grows. Real dampers have a washout filter (so a steady turn is not opposed), actuator limits and redundancy; none of that is modelled here.

Numerical checks on this page

(1) The RK4 time history of a 6 s sideslip kick is compared with the matrix exponential e^(At), computed by scaling and squaring: two completely different algorithms. (2) The sum and product of the four roots are compared with trace(A) and det(A), and the Routh-Hurwitz verdict is compared with the sign of the largest real part. (3) The Dutch-roll eigenvector is used as the initial condition so only that mode is excited; the measured period and damping ratio of the simulated yaw rate are compared with the eigenvalue. The experiment button runs a more realistic test: a 2 s rudder doublet, timing the yaw-rate oscillation and comparing it with the eigenvalue (it agrees to within a few percent when the Dutch roll is lightly damped).

Honest simplifications

This is a teaching model of a generic four-seat high-wing light aircraft (coefficients are in the range of values quoted in flight-dynamics textbooks, typed from memory, not from a particular aircraft). The model is linear and valid for small angles; the display warns when bank or sideslip leave that range. Not modelled: the product of inertia Ixz, propeller torque and slipstream, aeroelastic flexibility, compressibility, stall, ground effect, engine asymmetry, actuator dynamics, and the effect of sweep on the derivatives (changing the dihedral slider stands in for all dihedral-like effects). Sideways gusts are a random first-order process added to the sideslip rate. The visual bank and sideslip are multiplied by the exaggeration slider so that small angles are visible. This is not an aircraft handling-qualities or flight-training tool.

What to try

  • Load Light aircraft, cruise, press Sideslip kick and watch the nose wag and the wings rock together; the yaw-rate and bank traces in graph 1 oscillate with a period close to the one in the readouts.
  • Load Swept-wing airliner, yaw damper off, kick it, then load Same airliner, yaw damper on: the pole pair jumps left on the pole map and the wag dies out within about one cycle.
  • Load Slow approach: spiral divergence, hold a little aileron (+1 deg) or press Bank kick: the bank keeps growing slowly. Raise the dihedral slider until the spiral pole crosses back to the left half-plane.
  • Shrink the fin with Tiny fin: Dutch roll grows: the oscillation now grows (red region on the stability map).
  • Drag the white dot on the stability map (change dihedral and fin area) to see why designers cannot cure everything with dihedral.
  • Press Run Dutch-roll experiment and compare the measured period with the analytic one.
Loading model...
Loading Blender model...
Time history: sideslip, bank and yaw rate
Pole map (s-plane): Dutch roll, roll and spiral
Dutch-roll damping versus yaw-damper gain
Stability map: dihedral against fin area
Made with 🟠 Blender · Three.js